欧尚新星店二期工程地质勘探授标推荐报告

AuchanNingboXinxingRoadStoreProject(Phase欧尚宁波店二期工TenderEvaluation mendationGeologicInvestigationTheClient:NingboImmochanRealEstate 业主：宁波置PM:ShanghaiUManConstructionProjectManagement 项目管理：裕满建筑工程管

Date:May24th,日期：2011524欧尚宁波店二期工程地质勘探工程授标推荐报TenderEvaluationand mendationReportOfGeologicInvestigationContractorForNingboAuchanXinxingRoadStoreProject(PhaseNingboImmochanRealEstate 宁波置业AuchanHypermarketNingboXinxingRoadStoreisasupermarketinvestedbyNingboImmochanRealEstateCo..TheprojectlandlocatedatthecrossofHuanChengWestRoadandXinxingRoadinNingbo.Thelandareais67,685m2.Thetotalbuildingareaisabout170,781m2.Thewholeprojectisdividedintothreephases.Thebuild-upareaforthefirstphaseisabout118,646m2,including70,388m2abovegroundandthebasementisabout48,258m2.ThescopeofthistenderistheGeologicInvestigationcontractor.ThetenderingcourseoftheGeologicInvestigationcontractorwasimplementedaccordingtotheworkingscheduleoftheAuchanNingboXinxingRoadStoreProject.Detailedasfollowing:宁波欧尚店是宁波置业在宁波市环城西路和路路口新建一大型超市，总占地面积67685m2，约102亩;根目前方案总建筑面积约为170781m分期建设其中二期工程建设项目建筑面积18646m2其中建筑面积4828m2,地上建703882（2~5层。目前二期工程正在方案设计阶段。本次招标范围为二期项目的地质勘探工程。根据欧尚宁波店二期工程总体进度计划和地质勘探工程的招标安排，一、招标过程回顾tenderingcourseThetenderinvitationletterwasreleasedonMay20th,2011tothosethreecandidatesasfollowing:ZhejiangProjectGeologicalEngineeringCo.,(hereinafterreferredtoas“ZJGeo.”),NingboProjectGeologicalEngineeringCo.,(hereinafterreferredtoas“NBGeo.”),andNingboIndustryArchitecturalAnddesignCo.,(hereinafterreferredtoas“NBIndustryGeo.”).2011年5月20日向浙江省工程勘察院（以下简称省勘院、宁波工程勘察院（以下简称宁勘院、宁波市工业建筑设计研究（以Theintender sandquotationpricesfromthethreecandidateswerereceivedonMay23thof2011;2011523日陆续收到了三家投标单位返回的第一轮投标书和报价。UManorganizedthetenderevaluationandprovidesthetenderevaluationreportbaseonallthecommercial/technicaltendersandinterview2011524日,二、商务标分析commercialtender欧尚宁波店二期工程地质勘探工程的投标报价汇总详见下表Thetenderquotationsarecollectedasthefollowing报价汇总thefirst-turn项省勘宁勘工业钻孔414045控制556560静力触505550总进212523802450每米进尺单后总114000132000148000Wecanseefromtheabovetable:thequotationsfromallcandidatesonMay.23thof2011weredifferent,andthepricescouldbesortedasZJGeo<NBGeo<NBIndustryGeo,thereintothePerPricebiggestgapbetweenhighestpriceandlowestpricewasabout30%.AndthequotationpricefromZJGeoisthelowestprice.Accordingtotheysisofallcommercial s,thereasonablerankingofthethreetendersshouldbe:ZJGeo>NBGeo>NBIndustryGeo;三、技术标分析technicalproposalThistenderisforthegeologicinvestigationworksforAuchanNingboXinxingStore.Themainworkscouldbedepartedintotwoparts:theoneistheoutdoorgeologicinvestigationshouldmeetthegeneralprojectschedule;anotheroneisthegeologicinvestigationreportanddrawingcouldmeettherequirementforthedeependesignofworkingdrawings.UmanPMconsiderthekeydifficultpointofthisprojectistooffertheeligibleresultreportaccordingtothegeneralprojectschedule,andtofinishthegeologicinvestigationworksassortingwithdrawingcheckingcompanybasedontheschedule,qualityandsafety.本次招标为地质勘探。作为指定分包，其主要工作重点分为三部分：一部分野外勘探进场要求满足业主要求；另一部分提Thethreetenderershadtheireachadvantagesanddisadvantagesinthetechnicaltender .Attheprojectscheduleplanpart,theallconstructionschedulefromthreetendererscanmeettherequirementintender sbasically;attheprojecttechnicalteampart,theprojectteammemberscouldmeettherequirements,excepttheprojectteamfromNBGeo.上都能满足项目整体进度要求其中省勘院能在20天内提交成果并表示可对施工方案进行优化或增加施工设备来缩短工期在为本项目配 Accordingtotheysisofalltechnical s,thereasonablerankingofthethreetenderersshouldbe:ZJGeo>NBIndustryGeo>NBGeo;Thesubmissionsandinterviewresultsareas省勘院ZJTheestimationoflandgeologicconditions:cleardescriptionofthelandgeologicThetargetofgeologicinvestigationandtheobjectproblemsareWorkingtiesofinvestigation:deepdrillingfootageandreasonabledrillingholeMethodandmeasureforgeologicinvestigationandtestingarereasonable;勘探测试实施的方法、：勘探测试方案的方法合理；ThedraftedreportanddrawingsareQualitycontrolsystem;efficiencyqualitycontrolmeasuresandenoughtechnicalTheprojectteamofmaintechnician:thetechniqueteamcouldmeettheproject主要技术基本情况及技术配备：满足项目要求GeologicInvestigationSchedule:thescheduleplancouldmeetthe宁勘院NBTheestimationoflandgeologicconditions:cleardescriptionofthelandgeologicThetargetofgeologicinvestigationandtheobjectproblemsareWorkingtiesofMethodandmeasureforgeologicinvestigationandtestingare勘探测试实施的方法、：勘探测试方案的方法合理ThedraftedreportanddrawingsareQualitycontrolsystem;notgoodenoughqualitycontrolmeasuresandtechnicalTheprojectteamofmaintechnician:thetechniqueteamislackofthesimilarproject主要技术基本情况及技术配备：项目管理经验不太丰富GeologicInvestigationSchedule:thescheduleplancouldmeetthe工业院NBIndustryTheestimationoflandgeologicconditions:cleardescriptionofthelandgeologicThetargetofgeologicinvestigationandtheobjectproblemsareWorkingtiesofinvestigation:deepdrillingfootageandreasonabledrillingholeMethodandmeasureforgeologicinvestigationandtestingarereasonable;勘探测试实施的方法、：勘探测试方案的方法合理；ThedraftedreportanddrawingsareQualitycontrolsystem;efficiencyqualitycontrolmeasuresandenoughtechnicalTheprojec