2024高排放行业:低碳供应商的挑战与机遇世界经济论坛_第1页
2024高排放行业:低碳供应商的挑战与机遇世界经济论坛_第2页
2024高排放行业:低碳供应商的挑战与机遇世界经济论坛_第3页
2024高排放行业:低碳供应商的挑战与机遇世界经济论坛_第4页
2024高排放行业:低碳供应商的挑战与机遇世界经济论坛_第5页
已阅读5页,还剩131页未读 继续免费阅读

下载本文档

版权说明:本文档由用户提供并上传,收益归属内容提供方,若内容存在侵权,请进行举报或认领

文档简介

IncollaborationwithDeloitte

High-EmittingSectors:

ChallengesandOpportunitiesforLow-CarbonSuppliers

INSIGHTREPORT

SEPTEMBER2024

Images:GettyImages]

Contents

Foreword4

Executivesummary5

1Aviation10

1.1Currentemissionsprofile11

1.2TheFMCcommitment12

1.3Decarbonizationpathwaysinaviation12

1.4Supplierchallengesandopportunitiesinlow-carbonaviation13

2Shipping16

2.1Currentemissionsprofile17

2.2TheFMCcommitment18

2.3Decarbonizationpathwaysinshipping18

2.4Supplierchallengesandopportunitiesinlow-carbonshipping19

3Trucking21

3.1Currentemissionsprofile22

3.2TheFMCcommitment23

3.3Decarbonizationpathwaysintrucking23

3.4Supplierchallengesandopportunitiesinlow-carbontrucking24

4Aluminium27

4.1Currentemissionsprofile28

4.2TheFMCcommitment29

4.3Decarbonizationpathwaysinaluminium29

4.4Supplierchallengesandopportunitiesinlow-carbonaluminium30

5CementandConcrete32

5.1Currentemissionsprofile33

5.2TheFMCcommitment34

5.3Decarbonizationpathwaysincementandconcrete35

5.4Supplierchallengesandopportunitiesinlow-carboncement36

andconcrete

6Steel38

6.1Currentemissionsprofile39

6.2TheFMCcommitment40

6.3Decarbonizationpathwaysinsteel40

6.4Supplierchallengesandopportunitiesinlow-carbonsteel41

High-EmittingSectors:ChallengesandOpportunitiesforLow-CarbonSuppliers2

7Carbondioxideremoval(CDR)43

7.1Currentemissionsprofile44

7.2TheFMCcommitment45

7.3Decarbonizationpathwaysincarbondioxideremoval45

7.4Supplierchallengesandopportunitiesincarbondioxideremoval46

8Cross-sectorchallengesandopportunities48

8.1Lackofemissionsmeasurementmethodsandstandards50

8.2Availabilityandcostofinputs51

8.3Buyers’riskaversionandunfamiliaritywithdecarbonizedsolutions52

9Conclusion54

Contributors55

Endnotes57

Disclaimer

ThisdocumentispublishedbytheWorldEconomicForumasacontributiontoaproject,insightareaorinteraction.Thefindings,interpretationsandconclusionsexpressedhereinarearesultofacollaborativeprocessfacilitatedandendorsedbytheWorld

EconomicForumbutwhoseresultsdonotnecessarilyrepresenttheviewsoftheWorldEconomicForum,northeentiretyofitsMembers,Partnersorotherstakeholders.ThedocumentwascreatedincollaborationwithDeloitteConsulting,anentitywithintheDeloittenetwork.Thefindings,interpretationsandconclusionsexpressedhereindonotnecessarilyrepresenttheviewsofDeloitteandDeloitteshallnotbeliableforanylossinconnectionwiththisdocument.

DeloittereferstooneormoreofDeloitteToucheTohmatsuLimited,aUKprivatecompanylimitedbyguarantee(“DTTL”),its

networkofmemberfirmsandtheirrelatedentities.DTTLandeachofitsmemberfirmsarelegallyseparateandindependent

entities.DTTL(alsoreferredtoas“DeloitteGlobal”)doesnotprovideservicestoclients.Pleasesee/abouttolearnmoreaboutourglobalnetworkofmemberfirms.

©2024WorldEconomicForum.Allrightsreserved.Nopartofthispublicationmaybereproducedortransmittedinanyformorbyanymeans,includingphotocopyingandrecording,orbyanyinformationstorageandretrievalsystem.

High-EmittingSectors:ChallengesandOpportunitiesforLow-CarbonSuppliers3

July2024

High-EmittingSectors:ChallengesandOpportunitiesforLow-CarbonSuppliers

Foreword

By2050,50%ofemissionsreductionsneededtoachievenet-zerogoalsareexpectedtocomefromtechnologiesnotyetavailableatscale.1

DilipKrishna

ChiefTechnologyOfficerSustainability,

Deloitte

RobJohannAdriaanvanRiet

ProgrammeHead,

ClimateActionand

FirstMoversCoalition,WorldEconomicForum

Buildingearlymarketdemandforbreakthrough

technologiesisthereforecriticaltocatalysetheir

commercialadoptionandtakestepstowardsglobaldecarbonization.Giventhescaleandcomplexityofthechallenge,strategicreformsandengagement

fromgovernments,regulators,investors,purchasingfirms,researchersandthepublicarecrucialtohelpacceleratethedeploymentoflow-carbonsolutions.

TheWorldEconomicForum,alongsideprivate

firmsandresearchinstitutionsestablishedthe

First

MoversCoalition

(FMC)toenabletheaccelerationofbreakthroughtechnologiesandsendcredible,

large-scaledemandsignalstocarbon-intensive

sectors.FMCmemberspledgetopurchase

largevolumesofgoodsthatmeetscience-basedemissionreductiontargets.AspartofthisFMC

effort,theForumcreatedthe

FirstSuppliers

Hub

(FSH)withstrategicsupportfromDeloitte

Consulting.TheFSHisaglobalrepositorywheresuppliersprovideinformationontheirlow-carbonprojectstofacilitateinformation-sharingand

offtakeagreements.Thisdatabaseconnectsusers

withapoolofsuppliersaswellasconnectingsupplierstoFMCmembers,policy-makersandfinancierslookingtogrowtheavailabilityoflow-carbongoods.

Suppliersareakeyplayerinthisecosystemas

theyareresponsibleforpiloting,developingand

scaling-upthelow-carbontechnologiesneeded

globally.Theyareinstrumentalindrivinginnovationandbringingthesetechnologiestomarket,therebyinfluencingdownstreamemissionsacrosstheglobalvaluechain.

InformedbythelessonslearnedfromtheFMCandFSH,thisreport,developedincollaborationwith

Deloitte,providesananalysisfromtheperspectiveofthesupplieronthevaluechain,decarbonizationpathways,andchallengesandopportunitiesfor

scaling-uptheirtechnologies.ThisreportalignswithFMC’sfocusoncarbondioxideremovalandsixothersectorsthatrepresent~25%ofglobalgreenhousegasemissions:aviation,shipping,

trucking,aluminium,cement/concreteandsteel.

High-EmittingSectors:ChallengesandOpportunitiesforLow-CarbonSuppliers4

Executivesummary

Thisreportbeginsbyanalysingthesupplychain,decarbonizationpathways,challengesand

opportunitiesfordecarbonizingtheheavy-emittingtransportandmaterialsectorsfromthesupplier’sperspective.Itproceedstodescribethefollowingthreecross-sectorobstaclesforsuppliersin

acceleratingthecommercializationoftheirlow-carbontechnologiesandproposespotential

solutionsforsupplierstonavigatethesebarriers:

–Lackofemissionsmeasurementmethodsandstandards:Supplierscanengagewithindustryconsortiumsandinternationalbodiestoadvocatefortheestablishmentofsector-specificcarbonaccountingmethodologies

andstandards,whichcanhelpsecurebuyersandfinancing.

–Availabilityandcostofinputs:Through

strategiclocationdecisions,collaborationsto

expandaccesstoinputs,andengagementwithgovernmentandfinancestakeholders,supplierscanhelpovercomechallengestoincreasethesupplyofnecessarymaterialsandimprovethecost-competitivenessoftheirsolutions.

–Buyers’riskaversionandunfamiliarity

withdecarbonizedsolutions:Supplierscanleverageinnovativecontractingmechanismstoshareormitigateofftakeagreementrisk

andeducatepotentialbuyersonvaluingtheirsolutionsbasedonholisticeconomicand

climateimpacts.

Thisreportalsohighlightsuniqueopportunities

acrosseachoftheFMC’ssevensectors,organizedaroundthreeheavytransportationsectors,three

heavyindustrysectorsandcarbondioxideremoval,asfollows:

–Aviation:Opportunitiestoscale-upsustainableaviationfuel(SAF)includeflexibletermsinSAF

offtakeagreementssuchas“book

andclaim”schemesandexpansioninemergingmarketsforfeedstocksupplywhilepreservingsustainability.

–Shipping:Adoptionofemission-reduction

incentivessuchascarbontaxesproposed

byindustryplayersandregionalentitiescan

acceleratebusinessdevelopmentforsuppliersoflow-carbonshippingfuels.

–Trucking:Battery-electricvehiclefleets

frommultiplecompaniescanusealternativechargingmodels,suchassharedcharging

infrastructure,tosharecostsandconsolidatepoweruse.

–Aluminium:Thedevelopment,scaling-upandbroadcommercializationofemissions-free

smeltingtechnologies,renewableenergyuseinelectrolysisandhydrogen,andcarboncapture,utilizationandstorage(CCUS)presentpotentialopportunitiesfordecarbonizationintheprimaryaluminiumsector.

–Cement/concrete:Non-fossilalternatives

suchascalciumsilicatecementandnaturalpozzolans2offerpotentialresiliencetosupplyshortagesandalignwithevolvingregulations.

–Steel:Governmentinterventionslikethe

EuropeanUnion’sCarbonBorderAdjustmentMechanism(CBAM)andtheUSDepartmentofEnergy’sfundingforindustrialdecarbonizationprojectscanhelpbalancecostdisparities

betweensuppliersandincentivizeadoption.

–Carbondioxideremoval(CDR):Exploring

utilizationmarkets,especiallythoseinvolving

long-termsequestration,cancomplement

geologicstoragesolutionsandfurtherenhancecarbonremovalefforts.

High-EmittingSectors:ChallengesandOpportunitiesforLow-CarbonSuppliers5

FIGURE1:Globalgreenhousegas(GHG)emissions,bysector

3%

4%

2%

2%

6%

FMCsectors~25%

ofglobalGHGemissions

75%

8%

.Aviation

.Shipping

●Trucking

●Aluminium

●Cement

●Steel

●Othersectors

Source:

WorldEconomicF

orum.3

Basedontheinsightsfromthisreport,theWorldEconomicForumandDeloittearededicatedto

helpingacceleratetheadoptionanddemonstratingthefeasibilityoflow-carbontechnologiesin

heavy-emittingsectors.Relevantstakeholders,

includinggovernmentsandfinancialinstitutions,areencouragedtoembraceinnovativesolutionsformeaningfulemissionreductionsandexploretheresourcesavailablethroughtheFirstMoversCoalitionandFirstSuppliersHub.

High-EmittingSectors:ChallengesandOpportunitiesforLow-CarbonSuppliers6

TABLE1:FMCsectoremissions,pathways,opportunitiesandchallenges

GlobalshareofDeepdecarbonizationKeyopportunitiesKeychallenges

GHGemissions,pathwaysinlinewithFMC

bysectorcommitments

Aviation

–Highproductioncostsandpricepremium,comparedtoconventionalJetAfuel.

–Complexandcapital-intensivesupplychain,withsignificant

investmentrequiredtoscale-upproduction.

–SAFcompetingwithother

formsoftransportationforthesamefeedstock,particularlyinemergingmarkets.

–Sustainableaviationfuel(SAF)withlife-cycleassessment

(LCA)emissionsabatement

>85%(e.g.power-to-liquid,

Fischer-Tropsch,alcohol-to-jet,andHEFA)dependingontheproductionprocess.

–Nextgenerationnear-

–Growingpublicinterestin

reducingaviationemissions,drivingdemandforSAF.

–PolicyinterventionsandmandatesincreasingSAFdemandandproduction.

–Overcapacityinagricultural

areasinemergingmarkets,

offeringpotentialforfeedstockproductionforSAF.

–Collaborativeinitiatives(e.g.

JetZeroCouncil)bringing

togetherdifferentstakeholderstode-riskprivateinvestmentsandinnovatewaystoreduceaviationemissions.

~

3%

zeroemissionspropulsion

technologies,includingbattery-electric,hydrogenturbineandfuelcells.

–InternationalMaritime

Organizationandregional

bodieslikeEUsettingambitiousGHGreductiontargets.

–“Bookandclaim”schemesallowingshippingcompaniestocontributetoemission

reductionswithoutphysicallyusinglow-emissionfuels.

–Globalcarbontaxesandmass-balancemechanismstohelp

industryandregionalbodiesdriveinvestmentinlow-carbonfuels.

–Methanolproducedusing

low-carbonhydrogenand

sustainableCO2(biogenicorrecycledCO2,e.g.fromdirectaircaptureetc.).

–Ammoniaproducedwithlow-carbonhydrogenandnitrogen.

–Low-carbonhydrogenasacombustionfuel.

–Vesselscapableofusingzero-emissionfuels.

Shipping

2%

~

–Difficultiesforsuppliers

inobtainingfundingwith

appropriateriskappetiteandinvestmentsizetodevelop

andscale-uplow-emissionfuelprojects.

–Highcostofzero-emissionshippingfuels,comparedtofossilfuels,makingthemlessattractiveforinvestment.

–Gapsbetweensuppliers

andshippingcompaniesonacceptablevolume,offtakelengthandgreenpremiumlevels.

4%–BEV–Battery-electricvehicles

–Limitedandregion-

specifichydrogenrefuellinginfrastructure.

–HighcostsassociatedwithtransitioningtoBEVsandFCEVs.

–DifficultyforlogisticscompaniesmanaginglargeEVfleets

toobtainnecessarypower

allocationfromelectricutilities,duetofast-chargingneedsandhighenergyconsumption.

Trucking

~

–Establishmentofclear

–FCEV–Fuel-cellelectricvehicles(hydrogen)

–Zerotail-pipeemissionfuels

incentivesandregulationstoencouragedecarbonizationtechnologiesinmedium-andheavy-dutytrucking.

–Innovativebusinessmodelsliketrucking-as-a-service(TaaS)

andcollectivechargingfarmscanhelpoffsetthehighupfrontcostsoftransition.

–Proposedtaxcreditsandgrantsincountriespromoteinvestmentsinhydrogen

production,storageanddistribution,enhancingfeasibilityofFCEVs.

High-EmittingSectors:ChallengesandOpportunitiesforLow-CarbonSuppliers7

GlobalshareofDeepdecarbonizationKeyopportunitiesKeychallenges

GHGemissions,pathwaysinlinewithFMC

bysectorcommitments

Aluminium

2%

suchasinertanodesand

carbo-chlorinationcaneliminatesmeltingprocessemissions.

–Transitioningtorenewableenergyforelectrolysis

processescansignificantlyreduceemissions.

–Bypartneringwithsectoral

organizationstoprepare

procurement-ready

documentation,supplierscanhelpbuyersmakeinformeddecisions.

–Bycollaboratingwithwaste

managementsectorsand

governments,aluminium

manufacturerscansecure

recycledaluminiumand

increasesecondaryproduction.

Primaryaluminiumusing

breakthroughtechnologies,suchas:

–Electricorhydrogenboilers.

–Concentratedsolarthermal.

–Mechanicalvapourrecompression.

–Greenhydrogenorelectriccalcination.

–Inertanodes.

–Carbon-chlorination.

–CCUS(carboncapture,utilizationandstorage).

–Highcostofscaling-up

emergingrefiningtechnologieslimitsaccesstothese

technologiesinsomeregions.

–Maturenatureofaluminiumrecyclingleaveslessroomforimprovementandaddscompetitioninthematerialrecoverylandscape.

–Industryfaceschallenges

aligningongloballyacceptedstandardsanddefinitionsforlow-carbonaluminium.

–Emissions-freetechnologies

~

CementandConcrete

~

6%–Replacingclinkerwith

supplementarycementitiousmaterials(SCMs).

–Alternativechemistriesandprocessesthatreplace

limestone.

–Point-sourceCCUS.

–WithpotentialscarcityofSCMs,alternativeslikenon-fossilfly

ashesandnaturalpozzolanscouldbeused.

–Aslandscapeofclinker

alternativesevolves,suppliershaveopportunitytoshape

standardsandregulationstoaccommodatealternativechemistries.

–Supplierscancollaboratewithregionalvaluechainpartnersandregulatorybodiesto

developlocalizedapproachesandstandards.

–Highcostsofdecarbonizationandcompetitionforinvestmentwithothersectorspose

significantchallenges.

–Balancinghistoricallylocalindustryandtheneedfor

consistent,globalstandardsandcarbonaccounting.

–Asthesectortransitions,keyinputslikeSCMsmaybecomescarce,particularlyascoal

combustionandiron-makingblastfurnacesarephasedout.

High-EmittingSectors:ChallengesandOpportunitiesforLow-CarbonSuppliers8

Carbondioxideremoval(CDR)

N/A–DACCS–Directaircapture

withcarbonstorage.

–BiCRS–Biomasscarbonremovalandstorage.

–BECCS–Bio-energywith

carboncaptureandstorage.

–BCR–Biocharcarbonremoval.

–ERW–Enhancedrockweathering.

–Mineralization.

–Measurement,reporting

andverification(MRV)

systemsrunbytrustedthirdpartiescanassuresuppliersaboutthecredibilityand

durabilityoftheircarbonremovalefforts.

–CompaniesdemonstratingdemandfordurableCDR

solutionscanacceleratetheindustry’sgrowthanddrivedowncosts.

–Leveragingthecollective

purchasingpowerof

companiescanstimulatedemandandaccelerate

thecommercializationCDRtechnologies.

–Nascenttechnologies,lackofmatureMRVstandardsandlowsupportfrom

policy-makersresultinhighcoststhatlimitCDRuptake.

–Morerobustclimatepoliciestosupplementdemand-

sideeffortsandachievenecessaryscale.

–Effectivenessof

technologiescanvary

greatlybasedongeographicfactors(e.g.availability

ofcropland,biomass,renewablepower).

–CDRoftencriticizedfor

“legitimizing”continued

emissionsandavoidanceofotherabatementsolutions.Transparent,responsible

behaviourfromCDRfirmsisnecessarytocounteractthisperception.

Keychallenges

Steel

–Changestosteelproductiontolowercarbonintensitywilllikelyincreasefinalcost.

–Thefirstfirmstobringlow-

carbonsteeltomarketare

likelytostruggletoselltheirproducts,evenwhiletheyde-

risklow-carbontechnologiesforcompetitors.

–Longlife-cycleandhigh

costsofmajorsteelmakingassetsmaycomplicate

transitionplans.

–Absenceofglobalstandardsanddefinitionscanmakeitdifficultforsupplierstoalignproductionprocessesandforbuyerstomakeinformeddecisions.

GlobalshareofGHGemissions,bysector

Keyopportunities

Deepdecarbonization

pathwaysinlinewithFMCcommitments

–Policymechanisms(e.g.EU’sCarbonBorderAdjustment

Mechanism,CBAM)canhelpbalancecostoftransitioningtolow-carbonsteelproduction

andprevent“carbonspillover”.

–Organizationssignallinga

strongdemandforlow-carbonsteelcanminimizeriskof

investmentsand

driveinnovation.

–Useofcleanhydrogenand

biogascanhelpreduce

emissionsinsteelproduction.

–Direct-reducedironelectricarcfurnace(DRI-EAF).

–Scrapsteelelectricarcfurnace(Scrap-EAF).

–Novelreducingagents(e.g.low-carbonhydrogenor

gasifiedbiomass).

–Othertechnologies,suchas

electrowinningtomeltDRIto

makeitcompatiblewithBOFs(DRI-melt-BOF),replacementofpulverizedcoalinjection(PCI)withbiomass-orhydrogen-

basedalternatives,etc.

8%

~

High-EmittingSectors:ChallengesandOpportunitiesforLow-CarbonSuppliers9

1

Aviation

Aviationiswelloff-coursefromhitting

theIEA’sNetZeroEmissionsby2050

scenario.Long-termcontractsarecriticaltoacceleratethesupplyofSAFneededtodecarbonizetheindustry.

High-EmittingSectors:ChallengesandOpportunitiesforLow-CarbonSuppliers10

1.1Currentemissionsprofile

Therecoveryoftheaviationindustryhastransportsectorswilllikelyleadtoanincrease

acceleratedpost-pandemicinbothitspassengerintheaviationindustry’srelativecontribution

andcargosectors.Bytheendof2022,thetoglobalemissions.Whiletheindustryhas

USmarketplacealoneofferedover1.52trillionpioneeredseveralabatementandmitigation

passengermilestocomplementaglobalapproaches,industry-wideadoptionratesand

marketplaceofmorethan250billioncargotonne-supplierproductioncapacitiesofalternative

kilometres(CTKs)oftransportedgoods.4,5Thesolutionsindicatethataviationiswelloff-course

aviationindustryhasalargecarbonfootprintdueforthe100milliontonnes(Mt)ofCO2peryearNet

toitsdependenceonfuelconsumptionandalackZeroEmissionsby2050(NZE2050)scenarioof

ofviablealternativestojetengines,especiallyfortheInternationalEnergyAgency(IEA).7Without

long-haulflights.interventions,theemissionsintensityofaviation

fuelisexpectedtoremainconsistentlyhighat88

Althoughaviationaccountsforonly3%ofglobaltonnesofcarbondioxide-equivalent(tCO2e)per

greenhousegas(GHG)emissions,itsgrowthistonneoffuel,whileothersectorsseeadecreasing

outpacingothertransportsectors.6Additionally,business-as-usual(BAU)scenarioduetoefficiency

significantcarbonreductionsforecastinothergains(seeFigure2).

FIGURE2:Aviationemissionsintensitytrajectory,BAUscenario(tCO2e/tofaviationfuel)

CO2emissionsintensity

100

88888888888888

90

80

70

60

50

40

20

10

0

2019202020212022203020402050

Source:

WorldEconomicForum

8

.

30

High-EmittingSectors:ChallengesandOpportunitiesforLow-CarbonSuppliers11

TheFMCcommitment

FMCAviationcommitment

Airlinesandairtransportcompanies:

By2030,wewillreplaceatleast5%ofourconventionaljetfueldemandwithsustainableaviationfuels(SAF)thatreducelife-cycleGHGemissionsby85%ormorewhencompared

withconventionaljetfueland/orzero-carbonemittingpropulsiontechnologies.

Airfareandairfreightpurchasers:

By2030,wewillpartnerwithairtransport

operatorstoreplaceatleast5%ofconventionaljetfueldemandforourairtransportwith

sustainableaviationfuels(SAF)thatreduce

life-cycleGHGemissionsby85%ormorewhencomparedwithconventionaljetfueland/or

zero-carbonemittingpropulsiontechnologies.

*FMCin-scopetechnologiesinclude:

–Sustainableaviationfuels(SAF)withlife-cycleassessment(LCA)emissionsabatementof>85%.

–Nextgenerationnear-zeroemissions

propulsiontechnologies,includingbattery-electric,hydrogenturbineandfuelcells.

–OthertechnologieswithLCAGHGreduction>85%.

–ThesecommitmentsdonotincludeSAFwithLCA<85%,fossiljetfuelsandcarbonoffsets.

Fulldetailsofthecommitmentcanbefound

here

.

1.3

Decarbon

温馨提示

  • 1. 本站所有资源如无特殊说明,都需要本地电脑安装OFFICE2007和PDF阅读器。图纸软件为CAD,CAXA,PROE,UG,SolidWorks等.压缩文件请下载最新的WinRAR软件解压。
  • 2. 本站的文档不包含任何第三方提供的附件图纸等,如果需要附件,请联系上传者。文件的所有权益归上传用户所有。
  • 3. 本站RAR压缩包中若带图纸,网页内容里面会有图纸预览,若没有图纸预览就没有图纸。
  • 4. 未经权益所有人同意不得将文件中的内容挪作商业或盈利用途。
  • 5. 人人文库网仅提供信息存储空间,仅对用户上传内容的表现方式做保护处理,对用户上传分享的文档内容本身不做任何修改或编辑,并不能对任何下载内容负责。
  • 6. 下载文件中如有侵权或不适当内容,请与我们联系,我们立即纠正。
  • 7. 本站不保证下载资源的准确性、安全性和完整性, 同时也不承担用户因使用这些下载资源对自己和他人造成任何形式的伤害或损失。

评论

0/150

提交评论