下载本文档
版权说明:本文档由用户提供并上传,收益归属内容提供方,若内容存在侵权,请进行举报或认领
文档简介
1、literature reviewan analysis of dreisers sister carrie嘉莉妹妹文学评论an 18-year-old girl without money or connections ventures forth from her small town in search of a better life in theodore dreisers revolutionary first novel. the chronicle of carrie meebers rise from obscurity to fame-and the effects of
2、her progress on the men who use her and are used in turn-aroused a storm of controversy and debate upon its debut in 1900. the authors nonjudgmental portrait of a heroine who violates the contemporary moral code outraged some critics. a century later, dreisers characters continue to fascinate reader
3、s. the protagonist carrie is still a controversial character. many critics regard carrie as a “fallen woman”, and there are also some critics regard her as a “new woman”. many people hold such an opinion that sister carrie is a tragedy, in which carrie is described as an immoral woman and she had an
4、 empty life though she succeeded as a famous player at the end of the novel. they conclude that “it is impossible to possess true happiness in a money-oriented capitalism society.”(li qi-shan 45).jiang yu-qin says that “the city changed carrie,a once innocent country girl into a seemingly successful
5、 empty life.” (jiang yu-qin 135)in her abstract she points out that carrie represents the women who “experience desiring,chasing,struggling,falling and disillusioning.” carrie was successful eventually from material aspect, but still unhappy spiritually.we can find such a paragraph in peng dan-kuis
6、“theodore and his sister carrie ”, “she(carrie) has two persons to help her,but instead of getting better, she goes from bad to worse. actually there is no one who can be the saviour for carrie in the society. and she comes to realize it is impossible to be a success by working hard honestly.carrie
7、is just one of the many victims of the citys influence and of the capitalist society.” (peng dan-kui 75)from this passage, we can conclude that mr. peng takes carrie as a traditional woman victim in a corrupted society. in other words, he denies that carrie has her own motivates as an independent pe
8、rson. there are also many critics about the character carrie abroad.for example, in sister carrie and the hidden longing for love: sublimation or subterfuge? leon f. seltzer says, “the thesis of this study is carries longing is shown by dreiser(though never clearly understood by him )to be a longlin
9、g for love and emotional relatedness. such a longing, however, can never know fulfillment because, on one level, carrie is depicted as deficient in the capacity to love and, on far more essential level, her creator ( a man at once sterile and promiscuous, who.)was incapable of appreciating either th
10、e nature or possibiities of human intimacy.” (leon f. seltzer 192)we notice that seltzer descried carrie as a woman without the capability of love. here he also attacked dreiser.from so many critics, we can see there are really many people they dont appreciate carrie. they think she is degenerate, i
11、mmoral,cold-blooded, and without a lofty soul. but like everything has two sides, lots of other people have different viewpoints. they dont take carrie so simply, so traditionally. they argue that carrie, from some aspects, stands for “new woman”, which we can see in wu hong-yuns sister carrie under
12、 the unconventional discourse of feminism. first she declares that “carrie is not a victim ” of the captilist world, on the contrary, she is a victor, because “she (carrie) proves her ability and realizes her value through her own efforts in the capitalist fatherhood society.”(wu hong-yun 36) then m
13、rs. wu put forward the idea “carrie is not a immoral woman”, and she admires carrie highly with the words like “spirit independently”, “rational and witty”, “hard working”, “a new woman” from the feminist angle. she even justifies carries desire for material gains. she insists that carrie shows a qu
14、ality of “modern females”. its not superisingly that we can find almost the same words in wang gang-huas article. he even puts carrie to a new higher level. here is a paragraph from his carries desires and motives : “in short, carrie shaped her own perfect image through the reflection in mirror , th
15、e discernment and the confirmation of the surrounding people. this kind of self-shaping cultivated carries own consciousness, that is, she regards herself as an independent subject, and keeps an independent position in social activities. thereafter, carrie gradully stepped into being active from pas
16、sive.” (wang gang-hua 92)if we surf on the internet, we can find lots of critics about sister carrie. clare virginia eby says in his cultural and historical contexts for sister carrie, “dreisers evolutionary treatment of ethics in sister carrie ultimately verges toward the revolutionary, in that he
17、tries to get readers to suspend judgment on actions that would typically be condemned as immoral, such as carries premarital sex and hurstwoods theft. dreiser discourages readers from viewing carrie as immoral, instead drawing attention to the obsolescence of traditional moral standards. the ending
18、of the novel is especially significant in this regard, for dreiser breaks with long-standing literary tradition that fallen women must be fully punished, preferably by a grisly death. carrie, to the contrary, may be unfulfilled or lonely at the novels end, but she is very much alive and eminently su
19、ccessful in the eyes of the world.”he added, “carrie is not simply rebelling against her husband(hurtswood) but more significantly against the role that women were traditionally supposed to follow. as historian barbara welter describes the nineteenth century ideal for the white middle class, the tru
20、e woman was expected to be pious, pure, domestic, and submissive. however a competing model for femininity emerged in the u.s. around the 1880s. the new woman typically had a career and was economically independent. frequently new women aligned themselves with members of their own sex rather than in
21、 conventional marriages. carrie follows this pattern yet the typical new woman was better educated and frequently more politically inclined than carrie, and so we might best think of dreisers heroine as a transitional figure, moving from the victorian model of true woman toward the recognizably mode
22、rn new woman.” from these two paragraphs, we can know clearly about ebys understanding of carrie.too many critics about carrie exist from 1900 when dreiser finished the novel till now, and i cant cite them one by one. here i just classified them into two groups. from the totally different views, we
23、can see that different people does hold different opinions. to me, i also have my own understanding of carrie.first, i really cant agree carrie is a “fallen woman”. those who criticized that she is greedy for material gains and she loses her sense of morality when she pursues her desire, to me, they
24、 failed to understand the novel deeply and they failed to treat carrie equally as well. its quite true that carrie had sexual relations with two men, which maybe the most unbearable thing for those who said carrie is “immoral”, but when we read the novel, actually we can say that carries intention w
25、as to have a good husband. first she met drouet who attracted her with his beautiful clothes and fine manners which represented he belongs to a high class. that is very nature, as i say. carrie came from a poor peasant family and she wanted to search a better life in chigago. when she met such a you
26、ng man who was “ an experienced traveller, a brisk man of the world”(dreiser 9) and was so courteous to her. “it disposed her pleasantly toward all he might do.” (10)after carrie arrived the hansons, she found things disappointing. she did efforts to search a job, but she failed at last. drived by t
27、he desire for survival, she eventually accepted drouet. here we should notice that though the main reason carrie accepted drouet is he had the money to support her, but on the other hand, carrie did have some good feelings on him. besides, drouet promised to marry her. so at the beginning, the story
28、 went like lots of other love stories. poor young beautiful girl comes to a big city and wants a “better life”, then she meets a rich man who makes she believe that they love each other, inevitably she wishes a wedding with the man. that happens a lot now. but in the fact, the man didnt have a plan
29、to marry her. and later, carrie found another man who seemed worth her love. hurtswood stands for a calss higher than drouets. he was more attractive and he knew womens heart better. carrie once hesitated, but drouet really couldnt touch her heart any longer. drouet himself was not a guy who really
30、wanted to get married. so carrie didnt resist when hurstwood lied to her and brought her to new york. that happened on a base that carrie thought hurstwood would marry her and gave her a happy life. thats humans instinct. carries instinct is to survive and to live better. thats all. she didnt have a
31、ny intrigues like mrs.hurstwood. we still can say she is pure. she was just drived by the circumstances. so sexual relations with two men didnt make carrie a “fallen woman”. secondly, i dont agree completely that carrie is a “new woman”. when carrie met the living crisis in new york, at the beginnin
32、g, she still believed that hurstwood could made all things right. but later, she found hurstwood was falling rapidly. she tried to encourage hurstwood to find a job to support the family, but he failed. he couldnt find his place in the bigger city new york at all. but carrie didnt want to wait and d
33、ie. she got a job in a theatre,not so easily, then she left him. here we can often see many critics said carrie is “stone-hearted”. to me, carries behavior may be a bit cruel, but still can be forgave. think what an enviroment she lives in! she needs to live! i also explain her action as a result of
34、 her instinct.next, carrie made herself successful on the stage by a small chance. she got money and fame gradually. but these cant make her a “new woman”, because her success has much contingency. her self-consciousness hadnt be aroused untill she met ames, a young engineer. his influence causes ca
35、rrie to become disillusioned with her success as an actress in comedy and makes her desire to perform more dramatic works. he introduced some writers to carrie, and also gave some astonishing views about the surrounding people, which made carrie think he was a special man. from that, carrie started
36、to think about lots of other things deeply. i say, carrie at this moment is still not a “new woman”. she doesnt has her own understanding of the world. she still cant think and action as an independent woman.to sum up, i dont think carrie is “immoral”. when she is drived by her instinct to find a way to live, she has nothing to blame for. as jerome loving said, “for him(dreiser), man-all of humankindwas still halfway between animal instinct and ideal of human morality,and so alack of morality was to be expected.”(jerome loving 92 t
温馨提示
- 1. 本站所有资源如无特殊说明,都需要本地电脑安装OFFICE2007和PDF阅读器。图纸软件为CAD,CAXA,PROE,UG,SolidWorks等.压缩文件请下载最新的WinRAR软件解压。
- 2. 本站的文档不包含任何第三方提供的附件图纸等,如果需要附件,请联系上传者。文件的所有权益归上传用户所有。
- 3. 本站RAR压缩包中若带图纸,网页内容里面会有图纸预览,若没有图纸预览就没有图纸。
- 4. 未经权益所有人同意不得将文件中的内容挪作商业或盈利用途。
- 5. 人人文库网仅提供信息存储空间,仅对用户上传内容的表现方式做保护处理,对用户上传分享的文档内容本身不做任何修改或编辑,并不能对任何下载内容负责。
- 6. 下载文件中如有侵权或不适当内容,请与我们联系,我们立即纠正。
- 7. 本站不保证下载资源的准确性、安全性和完整性, 同时也不承担用户因使用这些下载资源对自己和他人造成任何形式的伤害或损失。
最新文档
- 2025交通赔偿协议书模板
- 临时工劳动签订协议书七篇
- 债务协议范本
- 全国赛课一等奖初中统编版七年级道德与法治上册《增强安全意识》获奖课件
- 重庆2020-2024年中考英语5年真题回-教师版-专题07 阅读理解之说明文
- 《商务数据分析》课件-市场定位分析
- 企业安全管理人员尽职免责培训课件
- 《卓越的销售技巧》课件
- 养老院老人康复设施维修人员福利待遇制度
- 新冠救治和转运人员的闭环管理要点(医院新冠肺炎疫情防控感染防控专家课堂培训课件)
- 公司驾驶员岗前安全培训
- 2023全国高考四套文言文真题挖空训练(答案)
- 2024年淄博星辰供水有限公司招聘笔试参考题库附带答案详解
- 2024年浙江绍兴市高速公路运营管理有限公司招聘笔试参考题库含答案解析
- 起重机械安全日管控、周排查、月调度制度
- 人教版七年级《道德与法治》上册各单元测试题 期末测试题(8套,含答案)
- 2023高考普通高等学校招生全国统一考试数学试题合集(共9套)
- T-CCTASH 002-2022 夹轨器标准规范
- WMT8-2022二手乘用车出口质量要求
- 退役军人技能培训课件
- 医院住院病人满意度调查表
评论
0/150
提交评论