版权说明:本文档由用户提供并上传,收益归属内容提供方,若内容存在侵权,请进行举报或认领
文档简介
IFPRIDiscussionPaper02156cemberAgriculturalCommercializationinEthiopiaTrendsDriversandImpactonWell-BeingNicholasMinotWarnerwdieMarketsMarkets,Trade,andInstitutionsDivisionAfricaRegionalOfficeINTERNATIONALFOODPOLICYRESEARCHINSTITUTETheInternationalFoodPolicyResearchInstitute(IFPRI),aCGIARResearchCenterestablishedin1975,providesresearch-basedpolicysolutionstosustainablyreducepovertyandendhungerandmalnutrition.IFPRI’sstrategicresearchaimstofosteraclimate-resilientandsustainablefoodsupply;promotehealthydietsandnutritionforall;buildinclusiveandefficientmarkets,tradesystems,andfoodindustries;transformagriculturalandruraleconomies;andstrengtheninstitutionsandgovernance.GenderisintegratedinalltheInstitute’swork.Partnerships,communications,capacitystrengthening,anddataandknowledgemanagementareessentialcomponentstotranslateIFPRI’sresearchfromactiontoimpact.TheInstitute’sregionalandcountryprogramsplayacriticalroleinrespondingtodemandforfoodpolicyresearchandindeliveringholisticsupportforcountry-leddevelopment.IFPRIcollaborateswithpartnersaroundtheworld.THORSNicholasMinot(n.minot@)isaSeniorResaerchFellowintheMarkets,Trade,andInstitutionsDivisionoftheInternationalFoodPolicyResearchInstitute(IFPRI),Washington,DC.JamesWarner)isaResearchCoordinatorinIFPRI’sMarkets,Trade,andInstitutionsDivision,AddisAbaba,Ethiopia.SamsonDejenesdejenearedocgiarorgisaResearchAnalystinIFPRI’sMarkets,Trade,andInstitutionsDivision,Washington,DC.TadiwosZewdiewasaResearchOfficeratIFPRI’sAfricaRegionalOffice,AddisAbaba,Ethiopia.IFPRIDiscussionPaperscontainpreliminarymaterialandresearchresultsandarecirculatedinordertostimulatediscussionandcriticalcommentTheyhavenotbeensubjecttoaformalexternalreviewviaIFPRI’sPublicationsReviewCommittee.Anyopinionsstatedhereinarethoseoftheauthor(s)andarenotnecessarilyrepresentativeoforendorsedbyIFPRI.2Theboundariesandnamesshownandthedesignationsusedonthemap(s)hereindonotimplyofficialendorsementoracceptancebytheInternationalFoodPolicyResearchInstitute(IFPRI)oritspartnersandcontributors.3Copyrightremainswiththeauthors.Theauthorsarefreetoproceed,withoutfurtherIFPRIpermission,topublishthispaper,oranyrevisedversionofitinoutletssuchasjournalsbooks,andotherpublicationsractAgriculturaltransformationreferstoaseriesofchangesinagriculturethatbothreflectanddriverisingincomeandeconomicdevelopmentmorebroadly.Whilethemacroeconomicpatternsofagriculturaltransformationarerelativelywelldocumented,lessisknownabouthowitismanifestedatthehouseholdlevel.Ethiopiamakesanexcellentcasestudyasithashadoneofthefastestgrowingeconomiesintheworld.Thispaperfocusesononeaspectofthisprocess:agriculturalcommercialization,thatis,theprocessthroughwhichanincreasingshareofagriculturaloutputissoldonthemarketratherthanbeingconsumedathome.Theanalysisusesthreenationallyrepresentativeruralhouseholdsurveyscarriedoutin2012,2016,and2019,includingapanelof1,900households.Theresultsshowthattheshareofmarketedagriculturaloutputhasincreasedsignificantlyovertheseven-yearperiod.Somewhatsurprisingly,thisincreaseisnotduetoashiftincropmixtowardmorecommercialcropsbutratheranincreaseinthedegreeofcommercializationofeachcrop.Usingacorrelatedrandomeffectsmodel,wefindmarketedsharetobesignificantlyrelatedtoageoftheheadofhousehold,farmsize,wealth,distancetoroad,rainfall,rainfallvariability,andregion.Althoughendogeneityisachallenge,descriptivestatisticsandregressionanalysisfurthersuggestthatagriculturalcommercializationcontributestohigherincome,largelybecausecommercialcropsgeneratehigherreturnsperhectarethanstaplegrains.Theresultsindicatethatthereisnoclearlinebetween“subsistence”and“commercial”farms.Alargemajorityoffarmshavesomecropsales,whilevirtuallynoneofthemsellalltheiroutput.Similarly,thecontrastbetweensubsistencecropsandcashcropscanbemisleading.Forexample,thevalueofstaplecerealsalesinEthiopiaisalmostthreetimesgreaterthanthatofcoffee,themaincashcrop.Wedrawlessonsfromtheresultsforthedesignofprogramstoraiseruralincomesbyfacilitatingmarket-orientedagriculturalproduction.KeywordsAfricaEthiopiaagriculturaltransformation,commercialization,povertycknowledgementsThisworkwasfundedbytheBillandMelindaGatesFoundation(BMGF).Itisoneoffivepaperspreparedundertheprojectentitled“AgriculturalTransformationinEthiopia:AssessingEvidenceofDriversandImpacts.”ThispapermakesuseofthreeroundsoftheAgriculturalCommercializationCluster(ACC)SurveysimplementedbytheInternationalFoodPolicyResearchInstitute(IFPRI)insupportoftheEthiopiaAgriculturalTransformationAgencyundertheprojectTechnicalsupporttotheEthiopiaAgriculturalTransformationAgency.”ThefirsttworoundsofthesurveywerefundedbytheBillandMelindaGatesFoundationandthethirdroundwasfundedbytheDanishInternationalDevelopmentAgencyandtheEthiopiaAgriculturalTransformationAgency.TheauthorsthankStanWoodandhiscolleaguesattheBMGFforprovidingguidanceandfeedbackonthispaper.TheauthorsalsothankMichaelMannofGeorgeWashingtonUniversityandChrisFunkoftheUniversityofCaliforniaatSantaBarbarafortheirassistanceinobtainingandprocessingtheCHIRPSrainfalldata.Finally,theauthorswishtothankShahidurRashid,whowastheprojectmanagerfortheimplementationofthethreeACCsurveys,guidingthedesignofthesurveysandtheinterpretationoftheirresults.1nAgriculturaltransformationdescribesasetofchangesthatoccurintheagriculturalsectorastheeconomyexpandsandincomerises.Thesechangesincludegreateruseofpurchasedagriculturalinputssuchaspurchasedseedandfertilizer,risingagriculturalproductivity,adeclineinsubsistencefoodproductionasfarmersshifttogrowingforthemarket,andtheexpandingimportanceofnonfarmactivitiesandincome.Thisispartofbroaderchangesintheeconomyknownasstructuraltransformation,inwhichtheagriculturalsectorgrowsmoreslowlythantherestoftheeconomysothatitsshareinnationaloutputdeclines,alongwithashiftinlaborfromruraltourbanareasandfromagriculturaltonon-agriculturalactivities.Atsomepoint,theprocessofurbanizationoftenresultsinaabsolutedeclineintheruralpopulation,leadingtorisingruralwagesandgrowingaveragefarmsize,bothofwhichcontributetoimprovedstandardsoflivinginruralareas.Agriculturalcommercializationreferstothegradualincreaseintheshareofagriculturaloutputthatissoldasopposedtobeingconsumeddirectlybythefarmhousehold.Thisisakeycomponentoftheprocessofagriculturaltransformation.Theimmediatecausesincluderisingagriculturalproductivitygeneratingasurpluswhichcanbesold,andimprovementsininfrastructurewhichfacilitatethesaleofagriculturaloutput.Itiswidelyassumedthatshiftingfromlowvaluestaplefoodcropstohigher-valuecommercialcropsraisesfarmhouseholdincome,althoughfirmlyestablishingcausalityisnoteasy.Thepatternsofagriculturaltransformationhavebeenextensivelyresearchedatthenationallevelusingcross-countryanalysisofthecompositionofgrossdomesticproduct(GDP),demographicdataonurbanization,andemploymentdatabysector.However,lessresearchhasbeencarriedoutonhowthesenationaltrendsaremanifestedatthehouseholdlevel.Thisstudywillfocusonthefollowingresearchquestions:•Hasthemarketedshareofcropproductionincreasedovertime?GiventherapideconomicgrowthinEthiopia,weexpectcropcommercializationtohaveincreasedaspartofthebroaderprocessofagriculturaltransformation.•Ifso,howdoestheincreaseincommercializationvaryacrossdifferenttypesofhouseholds?Forexamplewewouldliketoknowwhethertheincreaseislimitedtohigher-income,larger2farmersinfavorablelocationsordoesitextendtopoorerhouseholdswithsmallfarmsinremoteareas.•Whatarethehousehold-leveldeterminantsofcropcommercialization,suchasfarmsize,regionremoteness,sexofheadofhousehold,ageofheadofhousehold,andincome?•Giventhatriskplaysanimportantroleinagriculturalcommercialization,iscommercializationlowerinareascharacterizedbyloworunreliablerainfall?•Whatarethehouseholdcharacteristicsofmorecommercialfarmersandhowdotheydifferfrommoresubsistence-orientedfarmers?Ifriskisamajorimpedimenttocommercialization,wemightexpecthouseholdstostartbymarketingstaplecropbeforemovingtowardnon-perishablefoodcropsandeventuallyhigh-riskperishableandnon-foodcrops.•Doescommercializationcontributetohigherincomeandbetterstandardofliving?Manyprogramsassumethathelpingfarmersshiftintocommercialagriculturewillincreasetheirincome,butisthistrue?Theanswerstothesequestionshaveimportantimplicationsforthedesignandimplementationofprogramstoincreaseincomeandreducepovertyinruralareas.Shouldthegovernmentanddevelopmentpartnerspromoteagriculturalcommercializationtoimproveruralwelfare?Ifso,shouldtheprogramsbebroadbasedortargetedatcertaintypesofhouseholdsandcertainregions?Andwhataretheconstraintsthatpreventhouseholdsfromusingcommercialproductiontoraisetheirincomesandstandardofliving?ThispaperexaminesthetrendsandpatternsinagriculturalcommercializationinEthiopiaovertheperiod12to2019.Ethiopiamakesagoodcasestudyforseveralreasons.First,ithasexperiencedsomeofthehighestratesofgrowthinpercapitaincomeofanycountryintheworld.Thismakesitmorelikelythatwecanobservechangesinagriculturaltransformationoverarelativelyshortperiodofsevenyears.Second,theEthiopiangovernmenthaspursuedastrategyofagricultural-ledeconomicgrowth,makingsignificantinvestmentsinruralinfrastructure,creatinganenablingenvironmentforagriculturalgrowth,anddevotingresourcestoidentifyingandrelievingobstaclestoagriculturalgrowth.Third,thestudyisfacilitatedbytheavailabilityofthreehighlycomparablehouseholdsurveyswithrelativelylargesamples(3,000to5,000households)andasubsampleofalmost1,900householdsthatformapanel.ThethreesurveysaretheAgriculturalCommercializationClusterACCSurveysof2012,2016,andTheywerecarriedoutbytheInternationalFoodPolicyResearchInstitute(IFPRI)for3theEthiopiaAgriculturalTransformationAgency(ATA)withfundingfromtheBillandMelindaGatesFoundation.TheEthiopiaATAisasemi-autonomousdevelopmentagencywiththemandatetoaccelerateagriculturaltransformationinthecountrybytestingnewtechnologyandinstitutionalarrangementsTheATAwasoriginallyfundedbytheBillandMelindaGatesFoundationandlaterattractedsupportfromotherinternationaldevelopmentorganizations.TheATAfocusedonclustersofworedasinareasofhighagro-ecologicalpotentialwiththeideaofimprovingthedeliveryandadoptionofmoderninputs,increasingcropandlivestockproductivity,raisingthecompetitivenessofagriculturalmarkets,andgenerallyraisingthestandardsoflivinginruralareas.ThepaperisorganizedasfollowsSection2describesprevioustheoreticalandempiricalresearchonagriculturalcommercializationwithanemphasisonsub-SaharanAfricaandEthiopia.Section3providesanoutlineofthedataandmethodsusedinthisstudy.Section4describestheresultsoftheanalysisofthethreeACCSurveys.AndSection5summarizestheresultsanddiscussestheimplicationsforpolicyandprograms.PreviousresearchonagriculturalcommercializationOneofthemostsalientcharacteristicsofagricultureinlowincomecountriesistheimportanceofsubsistencefoodproduction.Mostfarmersgrowcropsandraiselivestockonarelativelysmallscale,withfarmsoflessthan2hectares.Alargeshareoftheircropproductionconsistsofstaplefoodcrops,includingcereals,cassava,andotherinexpensivesourcesofcalories.Whilefewfarmersarecompletelydisconnectedfromthemarket,alargemajorityselllessthanhalfoftheircropproduction.Inordertounderstandtheagriculturalcommercialization,itisimportanttobeginbyexplainingsubsistencefoodproduction.2.1.EconomicrationaleforsubsistencefoodproductionInanidealizedworldwithperfectinformationcompetitivemarkets,andnotransactioncosts,eachfarmerwouldproducethecropthatmaximizesprofit,sellallofthecrop,andusetherevenuetopurchaseautility-maximizingbasketofconsumergoods.Productiondecisionswouldbeseparable”fromconsumptiondecisionsinthatthelatterwouldhavenoeffectontheformerSingh,Squire,andStrauss,1986).Thus,aneconomicexplanationforsubsistenceproductionmustbelinkedtoaviolationofoneoftheseassumptions.4Forexample,marketsintherealworldarecharacterizedbytransactioncosts,thatisthecostofgettingtothemarket,findingabuyer,negotiatingaprice,andsellingtheproduct.Transactioncostsareparticularlyimportantforsmall-scalefarmerslivinginruralareas.IntheirseminalstudydeJanvryetal.(1991)showthattransactioncosts(includingthecostoftransportation)betweenthefarmandmarketcreatesagapbetweenthe(higher)farm-gatepurchasepriceandthe(lower)farm-gatesellingpriceofastaplefoodcrop.Thegapbetweenthepurchasepriceandthesellingpricewillbelargeforfarmerslivinginremoteareasandrelativelylargeforlow-valuestaplegrainsWhentransactioncostsaresignificant,theshadowpriceofthecropatthefarmlevelmaywellbetoolowtojustifybuyingthecommoditybuttoohightojustifysellingit.Thiscreatesasituationinwhichtherationalfarmerproducesenoughofafoodcropfortheconsumptionofthehousehold,neithersellinganyoftheproductionnorbuyingfromthemarket.Inotherwords,afarmeris“forced”tosupplyalmostallhisfoodrequirementsbecauseofthehighcostofsellingcropsorbuyingfood.Thisbreaks“separability”sincenowproductiondecisionsareinfluencedbyconsumptionpreferences.Italsomakesthefarm-levelsupplyinelastictopricechangesoverarangeofpricesandmakesaggregatesupplylessresponsivetopricesHightransactioncostscanalsoexplainlowuseofpurchasedinputslikeseedandfertilizer,whichreducesproductivityandincome.Asecondexplanationisrisk.Evenwithouttransactioncosts,riskmaybeanobstacletoaccessingagriculturalmarketsMosthouseholdsavoidrisk,butsmallfarmersandotherslivingatthemarginofsurvivalareparticularlyriskaverseintheirlivelihooddecisionsbecauseanegativeshocktoincomecouldthreatentheirhealthandsurvival.Producingafoodcropforownconsumptioncertainlyinvolvessomerisk:iftheweatherisbad,theharvestmaybetoosmalltofeedthefamily.However,producingcropsforthemarketinvolvesmultiplerisks,includingtheriskofpoorweather,theriskofadropinthepriceofthecashcrop,andtheriskofanincreaseinthepriceofthefoodtheyneedtobuy.High-valuecropssuchasvegetablesintroducegreaterproductionrisk(particularlyiftheyareperishable)andhighpricerisksbecausetheirpricestendtobemorevolatile.Thus,commercialcropproductionislikelytoberiskier,whichdiscouragefarmers,particularlythosethataremoreriskaverse.Thirdproducingsomecommercialcropsmayinvolveinitialinvestmentsthatareoutofthereachofsubsistencefarmers.Forexample,switchingfromsorghumtovegetablesislikelytoinvolvehighercostsforseed,fertilizer,andlabor.Andswitchingfromafoodcroptocoffee5requiresathree-yearwaitbeforethefirstharvest.Ineconomicterms,eveniftheinvestmentisprofitable,thefarmerdoesnothavethesavingsoraccesstocreditthatwouldbeneededtocovertheupfrontcosts.Thelackofaccesstocreditislinkedtomarketfailuressuchaslackofinformationonthepartoflendersaboutcreditworthinessofthefarmerandthehighcostsofenforcingrepayment.Insummaryeconomictheorysuggeststhat,inanidealizedworldofcompetitivemarketsandperfectinformation,farmerswhospecializeincropssuitedtotheiragro-ecologicalconditionsandsellthemwillearnmorethanfarmersproducingarangeofstaplefoodcropsfortheirownconsumption.However,inruralareasofdevelopingcountries,mostfarmersgrowarangeoffoodcropsfortheirownconsumptionandselllessthanhalfoftheircropoutput.Subsistenceagriculturalproductioncanbeexplainedbytransactioncosts,risk,andinvestmentcostsassociatedwithcommercialproduction.Relaxingthesethreeconstraintswouldallowfarmerstoproduceforthemarket,therebyraisingtheirincomeandimprovingfoodsecurity.2.2.LevelofcommercializationAsimplemeasureofcommercializationistheproportionoffarmersthatparticipateincommercialization,meaningthattheyhavesomecropsales.EarlierresearchinEthiopiaestimatedthataboutpercentofEthiopianfarmerswereinvolvedinsellingcrops(PenderandAlemu2007).Incontrast,arecentstudyfoundthattheshareoffarmersparticipatinginthemarketwaspercentinMalawi,80percentinUganda,and68percentinTanzania(Carlettoetal.,2017).Abettermeasureofcommercializationisthemarketedshareofcropproduction,whichtakesintoaccountthedegreeofcommercializationamongthosesellingcrops.Table1summarizesanumberofstudiesonhouseholdcropcommercializationbycountryandbycroptype.Themarketedsharerangesfrom17percentto72percent,butroughlyhalfoftheestimatesareintherangeof0percent.Ingeneral,theliteraturesuggeststhatalargeshareoffarmerssellatleastsomecrops,butmostsellarelativelysmallshareoftheirharvest.1Table1.EstimatesofthelevelofcommercializationStudyCountryCrop(s)Marketedshareofoutput(%)PenderandAlemu(2007)EthiopiaTeff24PenderandAlemu(2007)EthiopiaWheatGebremedhin&Jaleta(2010)EthiopiaAllcrops25Minotetal.(2015)EthiopiaWheatMamoetal.(2016)EthiopiaWheat27FAO(2019)EthiopiaWheatMurichoetal.(2017)KenyaAllcrops37FriesenandPalmer(2004)KenyaMaize40Carlettoetal.(2017)MalawiAllcropsCarlettoetal.(2017)TanzaniaAllcrops27.5Carlettoetal.(2017)UgandaAllcrops26.3Agwuetal.(2013)NigeriaCassava29.6Agwuetal.(2013)NigeriaMaize24.0Marteyetal.,(2012)GhanaMaize53Marteyetal.,(2012)GhanaCassava72Marteyetal.,(2012)GhanaAllcrops66Note:Itisnotclearwhetherthesefiguresrepresenttheaveragemarketedshareorthetotalvalueofsalesasapercentageofthetotalvalueofproduction.ThisdistinctionisdiscussedmoreinSection.DeterminantsofagriculturalcommercializationGiventhevariationinthecommercializationthenextquestionis:whathouseholdandcommunitylevelfactorsinfluence,oratleastarecorrelatedwith,agriculturalcommercializationAtthehouseholdlevel,mostdiscussionofcommercializationstartsfromthepremisethatfarmersmustproducebeyondtheirperceivedconsumptionneedsinordertoparticipateinthemarket,whichimpliesthathigherproductivityleadstohigherdegreeofcommercializationBarrett,2008;vonBraunandKennedy,1994).StudiesinmanyAfricancountrieshavereportedapositivecorrelationbetweenlevelsofproductionandcommercialization(e.g.,Carlettoetal.2017,Pender&Alemu2007,GebremedhinandJaletaMamoetal.2017).Thus,itisnotsurprisingthatmanystudiesfindthatthedegreeofcommercializationincreaseswithfarmsize(Carlettoetal.,2017).Researchalsofoundconsistentlystrongpositiveassociationsacrossmultiplecountries,cropsandyears,betweencropsales,livestockownership,creditaccessorothermeasuresofwealth.Conversely,lowerlevelsofoutputproductionaremainlyassociatedwithpoorassetownershipandlowadoptionofproductiontechnologies.2Giventhesmallfarmsizeofmanyfarmsinsub-SaharanAfricaandthedifficultyofgeneratingincomeabovetheminimumneededforsubsistence,itisnotsurprisingthatstudiesgenerallyfindthatfarmersareriskaverse(GuttormsenandRoll,2014;GebremedhinandJaleta,2010;Barrett,008;Aimin,2010;Pandey,2006).Riskaversioninhibitstheadoptionofpurchasedinputs,suchasfertilizerandimprovedseed,becausetheyinvolvecertaincostsanduncertainreturns.Forexample,Africanaverageuseoffertilizeris11kgofnutrientsperhectareofarablelandcomparedwiththeworldaverageof62kg/ha(Obayeluetal.,2021).Inthisway,riskaversionreducesproductivityandindirectlymakesitmoredifficulttoachievemarketablesurpluses.Thereisevidenceofthisinresearchwhichshowsasignificantimpactoftheagriculturalservicesontheintensityofinputuse,agriculturalproductivityandmarketparticipationofEthiopiansmallholders(Gebremedhinetal.,2009).Riskaversioncanalsodirectlyinhibitproductionforthemarketbecauseitexposesfarmerstopricerisksand(forperishablecrops)greaterproductionrisk.Anothersetoffactorsinfluencingagriculturalcommercializationarerelatedtoaccesstoinfrastructuresuchasmarketsandroads.Forexample,longdistancetothemarketleadstohighcostsoftransportation,limitingbothhouseholdlevelmarketparticipationandsalesvolume(FosterandBriceno2010;Barrett,2008).AstudybyAleneetal.(2008)inKenyashowedthattransactionscostshadasignificantnegativeeffectonthemarketparticipationoffarmersinKenyaWeakinfrastructureandlimitedaccesstomarketshasalsobeenidentifiedasanobstacletocommercializationindevelopingAsiancountries(Wiggins,2018).Severalstudiesfindthatpooraccesstoroadsisanimportantfactorinreducingthelevelofcommercialization(Keyetal.,Barret2007;PenderandAlemu,2007;Aleneetal.,2008;Yamauchietal.,2009;GebremedhinandJaleta,2010;Agwuetal.,2013).2.4.EffectsofagriculturalcommercializationAgriculturalcommercializationhaslongbeenseenasawayoutofpovertyforsmallholders(vonBraunBarrett,2008,GebremedhinandJaleta,2010).Theeffectsofcommercializationandsmallholderagriculturehasbeenthesubjectofseveralstudiesthattypicallyfocusontheimpactonpovertyandnutrition.iesexploringtheimpactofagriculturalcommercializationonincomeandpovertyhavefoundgenerallypositiveeffects,thoughthemagnitudedependsonthelocalconditions.Oneofthelargeststudiesexaminedtheimpactofagriculturalcommercializationonincomeusingsub-3nationalsurveysinsevencountries:Guatemala,Kenya,Rwanda,Zambia,thePhilippines,PapuaNewGuinea,andIndia(vonBraunandKennedy,1994;vonBraun,1995).Thisstudyfoundthatthatcommercializationsignificantlyincreasedhouseholdincomeinsixofthesevencases.AstudyconductedinKenyafoundevidencethatagriculturalcommercializationsignificantlyincreasedpercapitahouseholdexpenditureamongcommercializedfarms(Murichoetal.,2017).StudiesinKenyaandtheCentralAfricaRepublicreportapositiverelationshipbetweenvegetablecommercializationandwelfare(MuriithiandMatz2015,Ochiengetal.,2020).Researchontheimpactofagriculturalcommercializationonnutritionhasbeensomewhatmoremixed.Forinstance,thesummaryoffindingsofearlystudiesinTanzania,Kenya,andPapuaNewGuineaisinconclusive,withthesamecroptypedemonstratingeitherpositiveornoeffectsbothbetweenandwithincountries(Hitchings,1982;HarveyandHeywood,NiemeijerHoorweg,1994).Intheseven-countrystudymentionedabove,theimpactofcommercializationonnutritionwasexaminedinsixofthecasestudies,withthreeshowingimprovechildnutritionandthreeshowingnoeffectMore,recentstudiesinAfricaseemtoconvergetowardstheimportanceofcommercializationinimprovinghouseholdnutrition(OgutuetalCarlettoetal.,2017;Montalbano,2018).OnestudyofVietnamfoundmixedeffectsonnutrition,dependingonthetypeofcommercializationindicatorused(Linderhofetal.,2019).Higherincomemaynotnecessarilyimprovenutritionalstatusforvariousreasons.Therearecaseswherefarmersprioritizenon-fooditems,whichoftendependonknowledge,culture,andsocialgroups(RadchenkoandCorral,2018).SomestudiesintheAfricancontextexploregenderroleswithinthehousehold(vonBraunandKennedy,1994;Haddadetal.,1997;FischerandQaim2).Incomesfromcashcrops(oftenmalecontrolled)andfromfoodcrops(oftenfemalecontrolledmaybespentdifferentlydependingontheprioritiesofthememberwhoearnsitAccordingtoHoddinottandHaddad(1995),womentendtospendmoreonfoodanddietaryqualitythanmensonutritionimpactdependspartlyonwhoearnstheincome.Insum,mostresearchfindsthatagriculturalcommercializationhasapositiveeffectonincomeandpovertyreductionwhiletheimpactonnutritionismixed,withsomeevidenceofapositiveeffectandsomethatisambiguousor(occasionally)negative.2.5.AgriculturalpolicyinEthiopiaAfterthecollapseofitsSoviet-inspiredcentralizedplannedeconomy,Ethiopiaembarkedonamoremarket-orientedstrategywhichwouldsupporttheagriculturalsector.Beginningin1993,4thegovernmentlaunchedtheAgriculturalDevelopmentLedIndustrialization(ADLI)strategy,withanemphasisonincreasingagriculturalproductivity.Agovernmentdocumentexpressedthisasfollows:“theobjectiveistobri
温馨提示
- 1. 本站所有资源如无特殊说明,都需要本地电脑安装OFFICE2007和PDF阅读器。图纸软件为CAD,CAXA,PROE,UG,SolidWorks等.压缩文件请下载最新的WinRAR软件解压。
- 2. 本站的文档不包含任何第三方提供的附件图纸等,如果需要附件,请联系上传者。文件的所有权益归上传用户所有。
- 3. 本站RAR压缩包中若带图纸,网页内容里面会有图纸预览,若没有图纸预览就没有图纸。
- 4. 未经权益所有人同意不得将文件中的内容挪作商业或盈利用途。
- 5. 人人文库网仅提供信息存储空间,仅对用户上传内容的表现方式做保护处理,对用户上传分享的文档内容本身不做任何修改或编辑,并不能对任何下载内容负责。
- 6. 下载文件中如有侵权或不适当内容,请与我们联系,我们立即纠正。
- 7. 本站不保证下载资源的准确性、安全性和完整性, 同时也不承担用户因使用这些下载资源对自己和他人造成任何形式的伤害或损失。
最新文档
- 绘本动画制作课程设计
- 教师节服饰搭配课程设计
- 教师相关课程设计
- 教师怎样进行课程设计
- 教导主任培训课程设计
- 农业用地租赁协议书
- 教学做菜课程设计
- 故宫首饰鉴赏课程设计
- 操场积水整治措施方案
- 操作系统及构架课程设计
- 道路开口施工方案
- 咖啡厅室内设计PPT
- 北师大一年级数学上册期中测试卷及答案
- 小学二年级上册美术课件-5.17漂亮的钟-岭南版(14张)ppt课件
- 苏教版六年级上册音乐教案全册
- 江苏某市政道路地下通道工程深基坑支护及土方开挖施工专项方案(附图)
- 生物校本教材—生活中的生物科学
- 北京市建筑施工起重机械设备管理的若干规定
- 新建时速200公里客货共线铁路设计暂行规定
- 边沟、排水沟、截水沟施工方案(完整版)
- 实行特殊工时工作制实施方案
评论
0/150
提交评论