版权说明：本文档由用户提供并上传，收益归属内容提供方，若内容存在侵权，请进行举报或认领
文档简介
COVID-19
MACROECONOMIC
POLICYRESPONSES
INAFRICA
23
MacroeconomicResilience
inBeninandTogo
lanHeffernan&SalaviComlanApollinaire-Fabrice
IDRC·CRDI
Canada
AboutCoMPRA
TheCOVID-19MacroeconomicPolicyResponseinAfrica(CoMPRA)projectwas
developedfollowingacallforrapidresponsepolicyresearchintotheCOVID-19
pandemicbytheIDRC.Theproject’soverallgoalistoinformmacroeconomicpolicy
developmentinresponsetotheCOVID-19pandemicbylowandmiddle-income
countries(LMICs)anddevelopmentpartnersthatresultsinmoreinclusive,climate-
resilient,effectiveandgender-responsivemeasuresthroughevidence-basedresearch.
ThiswillhelptomitigateCOVID-19’ssocialandeconomicimpact,promoterecovery
fromthepandemicintheshorttermandpositionLMICsinthelongertermfora
moreclimate-resilient,sustainableandstablefuture.TheCoMPRAprojectwillfocus
broadlyonAfricancountriesandspecificallyonsixcountries(Benin,Senegal,Tanzania,
Uganda,NigeriaandSouthAfrica).SAIIAandCSEA,astheleadimplementing
partnersforthisproject,alsoworkwiththinktankpartnersinthesecountries.
OurDonor
ThisprojectissupportedbytheInternationalDevelopmentResearchCentre(IDRC).TheIDRCisaCanadianfederalCrowncorporation.ItispartofCanada’sforeign
affairsanddevelopmenteffortsandinvestsinknowledge,innovation,andsolutionstoimprovethelivesofpeopleinthedevelopingworld.
Recommendations
Benin
•Beninshouldcloselymonitorandsignificantlyreduceitsdebt-to-GDPlevelsduringthenext
periodofsustainedeconomicgrowth.Althoughthislevelofdebtmaybeacceptableatthe
presenttime,loweringthedebt-to-GDPratiowillallowthegovernmenttoborrowmoreeasilyandatalowerratetofinancespendingduringfuturecrises.
•Beninshouldworktowardsincreasingitstaxbasebyincentivisingfirmstomoveintotheformalsector.Thiswouldallowthegovernmenttousefiscalpolicymoreefficientlyduringcrisesandalsoreducedebtduringperiodsofeconomicgrowth.
•Benin’straderelationswithNigeriashouldbeimproved.Thiscanbeaccomplishedby
improvingmonitoringofgoodsandservicescrossinglandborderswiththespecificaimofreducingre-exports.
Togo
•Togoshouldimplementgovernancereforms.AllofthenationalcrisesinTogohavebeen
associatedwithuncertaintyregardingthecountry’spoliticalinstitutionsanditisdifficultto
implementcounter-cyclicalpoliciestooffsetthenegativeimpactofgovernancecrisesonGDP.
•Creatingmoreinclusivepoliticalandeconomicinstitutionscouldhelptopreventpoliticalcrisesfromarising.
•Togoshouldcloselymonitorinflationandmaintainalowgrowthrateinthemoneysupply.Contractionarypolicymayberequiredtopreventfurtherincreasesininflation.
Executivesummary
ThispolicybriefingprovidesacomparativeanalysisofthemacroeconomicresilienceofBenin
andTogotoendogenousandexogenousshocksoveratwenty-yearperiodfrom2000to2020.Bothcountrieshaveexperiencednumerousshocksoverthisperiod;however,asmallselectionofshocksineachcountryhaveindeedresultedinnegativegrowth.Theoverridingreasonfor
analysingtheimpactoftheseshocksistoprovideinsightstopolicymakersonhowbestto
enhanceresilienceinthetwocountries.TogoandBeninarecomparedastheyareneighbouringfrancophonecountriesofasimilarsizewedgedbetweenAnglophoneregionalpowerhouses
GhanaandNigeriainWestAfrica.BothcountriesarealsomembersofECOWASandWAEMU.Togohasbeenbesetbygovernancecrisesformostoftheperiod,whereasBeninhasenjoyedamuchgreaterlevelofpoliticalandeconomicstability.Nonetheless,itisinterestingtonotethatBenin,becauseofitsgreaterintegrationwiththeregionalandglobaleconomy,hasbeenmoresignificantlyimpactedbyshocksasdemonstratedbyitsvolatileGDPgrowthperformance.
Togo’seconomicperformance,incomparison,hasbeenlargelyshieldedbyitskeyexport,
phosphates,whichhasstrengtheneditsabilitytoapplycounter-cyclicalpoliciestosmooththeimpactofshocksonitseconomicperformance.
3MacroeconomicResilienceinBeninandTogo
Introduction
Togoisclassifiedasalow-incomecountry.Itisoneofthepoorestcountriesintheworld,ranked195thof214countrieswithaGDPpercapitaof$918.4in2022.1Benin,incontrast,wasreclassified
asalower-middle-incomecountryin2019fromitsformerlow-incomestatusbytheWorldBankandhadaGDPpercapitaof$1,303.2in2022.2Figure1displaystherelativesizeofthetwo
countriesintermsoftheirpopulationandGDPin2020.Beninisslightlybigger,bothinterms
ofpopulationandGDP,butgeographicallyalmosttwicethesizeofTogo.WhenconsideringthecompositionofGDPinthetwocountries,weseeinFigure2thatbotharenetimportersandthecountrieshavesimilarratiosofconsumption,governmentspendingandinvestmenttoGDP.
Inbothcountries,theservicesectorisbyfarthelargestsectorandrepresentedapproximately
50%ofdomesticproductionin2022.3Bothcountries’exportsarenotverydiversified.Togo’s
largestexportsaremineralsandrepresentapproximately50%ofexports.4Benin’slargestexportiscotton,whichrepresentsapproximately65%ofexports.5Bothcountrieshavehighlevelsof
povertywith38%ofthepopulationofBeninand45%ofTogo’spopulationlivinginpovertyin2018.6
Figure1PopulationandGDPinBeninandTogo
Togo4201539
Togo
8442580
GDP
2020($)
Population
2020
Benin
8705923
Benin
12643123
Sources:TheWorldBank,/indicator/SP.POP.TOTL?locations=BJ-TG;TheInternationalMonetaryFund,https://data.imf.org/?sk=4c514d48-b6ba-49ed-8ab9-52b0c1a0179b
1TheWorldBank,‘GDPpercapita(currentUS$)–Togo,Benin|Data()’,/indicator/NY.GDP.PCAP.CD?locations=TG-BJ.
2TheWorldBankGDPperCapita;RepublicofBenin,MinistryofEconomyandFinance,Communique,‘Beninisnowamiddleincomecountry’,Benin,7March2020.
3TheCentralBankofWestAfricanStates,‘GDPanditsComponentsatNominalValues’.
4UnitedNations,UNComtradeDatabase,/.
5UnitedNations,UNComtradeDatabase.
6TheWorldBank,‘PovertyHeadcountRatioatNationalPovertyLines(PercentofPopulation)–Togo,Benin’.
4MacroeconomicResilienceinBeninandTogo
TOGO
Figure2CompositionofGDPinBeninandTogo(2020)
-5%
-485257,58
24%
2297387,56
10%
989055,23
61%
5904737,37
BENIN
-8%
-390000,00
20%
992098,83
11%
570400,00
61%
3029040,17
Consumption
Government
Investment
Netexports
Source:TheInternationalMonetaryFund,/?sk=4c514d48-b6ba-49ed-8ab9-52b0c1a0179b
ThenatureofmacroeconomiccrisesinBeninandTogo
Thispaperdistinguishesbetweennationalcrisesthatoriginatewithinthecountryandregional/globalcrisesthatoriginateoutsidethecountryandaffecttheregionand/ortheworld.Themostprominentregional/globalcrisesobservedinBeninandTogoincludethe2008globalfinancial
crisis,extensivefloodinginWestAfricain2010,theoutbreakofEbolain2014inbothcountries,
andtheglobalCOVID-19crisisof2020.BeninandTogowerenotseverelyaffectedfromahealthperspectivebyeitherCOVID-19orEbola,andneithercountryhadasinglecaseofEbola,butbothcountrieswereaffectedbytheglobaleconomicconsequencesofthepandemics.
NationalcriseswhichaffectedBeninduringthisperiodincludeatradedisputewithNigeria
in2005andpoliticalinstabilityinthecountrysurroundingtheunsuccessfulimpeachmentof
PresidentBoniYayibecauseofhisallegedinvolvementinaPonzischemein2010.7Thetrade
disputewasduetoNigeriaincreasingthenumberofprohibitedgoodsthatcouldbeimportedinanattempttolimittheamountofgoodsbeingreimportedfromBeninintoNigeria.8National
crisesinTogoduringthisperiodwerealmostentirelytheresultofpoliticalinstabilityrelatedto
7Reuters,‘BeninpresidentaccusedofroleinPonzischeme’,/article/benin-swindle-idUSLDE67I1RP20100819/.
8AfricanDevelopmentBank(AFDB),‘BeninCountryStrategyPaper2005-2009’,/en/documents/document/2005-2009-benin-country-strategy-paper-12963.
5MacroeconomicResilienceinBeninandTogo
Realgrowthrates
2000
2001
2002
2003
2004
2005
2006
2007
2008
2009
2010
2011
2012
2013
2014
2015
2016
2017
2018
2019
2020
2021
thecountry’spoliticalinstitutionsandelectionsoccurringrespectivelyin2000,2004,2010,2012and2020.Politicalinstabilitywasparticularlyevidentfrom2004,priortothedeathofpresidentGnassingbéEyadémain2005,whowascontroversiallysucceededbyhissonFaureGnassingbéEyadémaafterabriefinterregnumfollowinghisfather’sdeath.
Figures3and4plottheevolutionofGDPpercapitagrowthinBeninandTogo.Theredshadedareasrepresentnationalcrisesandtheblueareasrepresentregional/globalcrises.Overall,
Benin’seconomicperformancewasmorevolatileasitwasseeminglymoreexposedtoglobal
andregionalshocksthanTogo’seconomy.Itisnoteworthythatoverthesametimeperiodbotheconomiesappearedtobecomemoreresilienttoexogenousandendogenousshocks.InBenin,theeconomydidnotexperiencenegativegrowthratesafter2014whereasinTogo,thecountrydidnotexperiencegrowthfrom2007to2019.
Figure3Benin:EvolutionofGDPpercapita
0,05
0,04
0,03
0,02
0,01
0
-0,01
-0,02
Crisis3
Natural
disasters
Crisis2
Global
financialcrisis
Crisis1
Monetaryshocks
NATIONALREGIONALREGIONALREGIONALREGIONAL
Crisis6
COVID-19
NATIONAL
Crisis4
Financialcrisis
Crisis5
Ebola
Source:TheCentralBankofWestAfricanStates,GDPanditsComponentsatNominalValues,/rapportPredefini.php
6MacroeconomicResilienceinBeninandTogo
Realgrowthrates
2000
2001
2002
2003
2004
2005
2006
2007
2008
2009
2010
2011
2012
2013
2014
2015
2016
2017
2018
2019
2020
2021
Figure4Togo:EvolutionofGDPpercapita
0,06
0,04
0,02
0
-0,02
-0,04
-0,06
NATIONAL
Crisis1
Presidentialelections
NATIONAL
Crisis2
Presidentialelections
REGIONAL
Crisis3
Global
financialcrisis
REGIONAL
Crisis4
Naturaldisasters
NATIONAL
Crisis5
Presidentialelections
REGIONAL
Crisis6
Ebola
REGIONAL
Crisis8
COVID-19
NATIONAL
Crisis7
Presidential
elections
Source:TheCentralBankofWestAfricanStates,GDPanditsComponentsatNominalValues,/rapportPredefini.php
Table1Averagegrowthratesduringcrisisperiods
GDP
Consumption
Government
Investment
Exports
Benin
-0.35%
-1.82%
4.25%
-1.52%
-7.98%
Togo
-0.34%
-1.12%
2.70%
-1.05%
-4.10%
Source:TheCentralBankofWestAfricanStates,GDPanditsComponentsatNominalValues,/rapportPredefini.php
ThecrisesinthetwocountrieshadvaryingimpactsonthecomponentsofGDP.Table1presentstheaveragegrowthrateofthecomponentsofGDPduringtheperiodsofcrisis.InbothBenin
andTogo,consumptionwasnegativelyaffectedduringperiodsofnegativegrowth.ConsumptiondeclinedslightlymoreinBeninthaninTogo(approximately2%and1%respectively).However,
therewasasharpcontrastbetweenthetwocountrieswithrespecttogovernmentspending.ThegrowthrateofgovernmentspendinginBeninwas4.25%duringperiodsofnegativeGDPgrowth.ThiswasconsistentwiththegovernmentofBeninimplementingcounter-cyclicalgovernment
spendingtooffsetthenegativeeffectsofthecrises.InTogo,alowergrowthrateofgovernmentspendingduringtheseperiodswasapparent.Finally,weobservethatinvestmentandexports
weremorenegativelyaffectedinBeninduringperiodsofcrisesthaninTogo.
7MacroeconomicResilienceinBeninandTogo
Governmentexpenditurepercapita(Growthrate)
Taxrevenuepercapita(Growthrate)
2000
2001
2002
2003
2004
2005
2006
2007
2008
2009
2010
2011
2012
2013
2014
2015
2016
2017
2018
2019
2020
Generalgovernmentnetlending/borrowing(%ofGDP)
Figures5and6showfiscalpolicyresponsetoeconomicfluctuationsinBeninandTogo
respectively.Thefiguresplotthegrowthratesoftaxrevenueperpersonandgovernment
expenditure.Alsoincludedinthefiguresisnetlending/borrowingasapercentageofGDP.In
Benin,taxrevenuetendedtodeclineduringperiodsofcriseswhilegovernmentexpenditure
increasedbeforedecreasingfollowingcrises.Thisreflectsresponsiblefiscalpolicymaking.Also
notethenegativegrowthrateintaxrevenuein2012inBenin.Thiscouldbeexplainedbya
reformtocustomsproceduresatthePortofCotonouthatcauseddiversionsoftradetoports
inneighbouringcountries.9Thereformsincluded‘(i)aone-stopwindowatthePortofCotonou;(ii)anenhancedimport-value-verificationprogram;and(iii)acustoms-valuationsystembasedonactualtransactionalvalues’.10ThegovernmentofBeninrespondedresponsiblybyreducing
expenditureproportionally.Consistentwiththeoverallexpenditurepattern,government
Figure5Benin:Taxrevenue,governmentspendinganddebttoGDP
0,5
0,4
0,3
0,2
0,1
0
-0,1
-0,2
NATIONAL
Crisis1
Monetaryshocks
REGIONAL
Crisis2
Global
financialcrisis
NATIONAL
Crisis4
Financialcrisis
REGIONAL
Crisis3
Naturaldisasters
REGIONAL
Crisis5
Ebola
REGIONAL
Crisis6
COVID-19
-2
-3
-1
1
0
-4
-5
Taxrevenuepercapita(Growthrate)
Governmentexpenditurepercapita(Growthrate)
Generalgovernmentnetlending/borrowing(%ofGDP)
Sources:InternationalMonetaryFundDatamapper,/external/datamapper/profile/BEN;UnitedNationsGovernmentRevenueDataset,/content/grd-data-download
9InternationalMonetaryFund,‘Benin:ThirdReviewUndertheExtendedCreditFacilityArrangement’,
/view/journals/
002/2012/099/article-A001-en.xml#A01fig02.
10IMF,Benin:ThirdReview.
8MacroeconomicResilienceinBeninandTogo
Governmentexpenditurepercapita(Growthrate)
Taxrevenuepercapita(Growthrate)
2000
2001
2002
2003
2004
2005
2006
2007
2008
2009
2010
2011
2012
2013
2014
2015
2016
2017
2018
2019
2020
Generalgovernmentnetlending/borrowing(%ofGDP)
3
2
1
0
-1
-2
-3
-4
-5
-6
-7
-8
Figure6Togo:Taxrevenue,governmentspendinganddebttoGDP
0,6
0,5
0,4
0,3
0,2
0,1
0
-0,1
-0,2
-0,3
-0,4
NATIONAL
Crisis2
Presidentialelections
NATIONAL
Crisis1
Presidentialelections
REGIONAL
Crisis3
Global
financialcrisis
REGIONAL
Crisis6
Ebola
REGIONALNATIONAL
Crisis4Crisis5
NaturalPresidential
disasterselections
NATIONAL
Crisis7
Presidential
elections
REGIONAL
Crisis8
COVID-19
Taxrevenuepercapita(Growthrate)
Governmentexpenditurepercapita(Growthrate)
Generalgovernmentnetlending/borrowing(%ofGDP)
Sources:InternationalMonetaryFundDatamapper,/external/datamapper/profile/BEN;UnitedNationsGovernmentRevenueDataset,/content/grd-data-download
netlendingdecreasedduringcrisisperiodsandincreasedafterwards.Thissuggeststhatthe
governmentuseddebttofinancestimulusspendingduringcrisesandactivelyattemptedto
reducethestockafterwards.However,itshouldbenotedthatdebtstockhadsteadilyincreasedfrom2007andacceleratedduringthepandemic.Thiscanbeseenbynetlendingwhichhad
beennegativeforalmosttheentiresampleperiod.Anegativenetlendingpositionimpliesthatthegovernmentisborrowing.However,grossdebtremainedlowfortheregionat52%ofGDPin2023.ItisimportantfortheBeningovernmenttomakesurethatitremainssustainable.11
11InternationalMonetaryFund,‘CentralGovernmentGrossDebt’,/external/datamapper/GGXWDG_NGDP@WEO/BEN?zoom=BEN&highlight=BEN.
9MacroeconomicResilienceinBeninandTogo
Inflation,consumerprices(Annual%)
2000
2001
2002
2003
2004
2005
2006
2007
2008
2009
2010
2011
2012
2013
2014
2015
2016
2017
2018
2019
2020
Moneysupply(Growthrate)
1,00
0,80
0,60
0,40
0,20
0
-0,20
ForTogo,governmentspendingtendedtobeprocyclicalduringperiodsofnationalcrises.
Thegrowthratedecreasedduringallnationalcrises.Duringregionalcrises,governmentspendingwaslesspredictable.Theonlyclearexampleofcounter-cyclicalgovernmentspendingduring
regionalcriseswasduringtheCOVID-19pandemic,whichsawalargeincreaseinthegrowthrateofgovernmentspending.Inaddition,taxrevenuetendedtobeaffectedbynationalcrisesmore
thanbyglobal/regionalcrises.Withtheexceptionofthepresidentialelectionsin2018,allnationalcriseswereassociatedwithanegativegrowthrateintaxrevenue.Forglobal/regionalcriseswe
sawanegativegrowthratefortaxrevenueduringthefloodingin2010andduringtheEbolacrisis.
Asfornetlending/borrowing,thisappearstohavebeenrelativelyunrelatedtobothnationalandglobal/regionalcrises.Fortheperiod2008to2016,netlendingdeclineddramatically.
Thisindicatesthatthegovernmentspentmorethantherevenueitgenerated.Netborrowing
increaseddramaticallypriortothe2018nationalcrisis,whichindicatesarelativelybalanced
budgetwithnetlendingbeingclosetozero.Finally,netlendingdecreaseddramaticallyduringtheCOVID-19crisisasaresultofincreaseddebttofinancecounter-cyclicalgovernmentspending.
Figure7Benin:Moneysupply(M1)andinflation
9
8
7
6
5
4
3
2
1
0
-1
-2
REGIONAL
Crisis3
Naturaldisasters
NATIONAL
Crisis1
Monetaryshocks
REGIONAL
Crisis4
Ebola
REGIONAL
Crisis2
Global
financial
crisis
NATIONAL
Crisis4
Financial
Crisis
REGIONAL
Crisis5
COVID-19
Inflation,consumerprices
Moneysupply
Source:AfricanDevelopmentBankSocioEconomicDatabase,1960–2022,/nbyenxf/afdb-socio-economic-database-1960-2022#.
10MacroeconomicResilienceinBeninandTogo
Inflation,consumerprices(Annual%)
2000
2001
2002
2003
2004
2005
2006
2007
2008
2009
2010
2011
2012
2013
2014
2015
2016
2017
2018
2019
2020
Moneysupply(Growthrate)
0,8
0,7
0,6
0,5
0,4
0,3
0,2
0,1
0
-0,1
Next,weconsiderthemonetarypolicyresponseinthetwocountriesbyexaminingthegrowth
rateofthemoneysupply(M1)andtheinflationrate.InBenin,moneygrowthtendedtoincreaseduringcrises,withtheonlyexceptionbeingthenaturaldisastersin2010wherethemoneysupplydeclined(Figure7).Theexpansionsinthemoneysupplygenerallyinducedlargefluctuationsin
inflationalthough,sincethebeginningof2014,inflationhasbeenmuchmorestable.
InTogo,theresponseofmonetarypolicytocriseswaslessconsistentthanhadbeenthecaseinBenin.Duringthefirst,secondandthirdpresidentialelections,andtheCOVID-19pandemic,monetarypolicywasexpansionary(Figure8).
Figure8Togo:Moneysupply(M2)andinflation
10
8
6
4
2
0
-2
REGIONALREGIONALNATIONAL
NATIONAL
Crisis1
Presidentialelections
REGIONAL
Crisis6
Ebola
REGIONAL
Crisis8
NATIONAL
Crisis7
NATIONAL
Crisis3
Global
financialcrisis
Crisis4
Naturaldisasters
Crisis5
Presidentialelections
Crisis2
PresidentialCOVID-19elections
Presidential
elections
Inflation,consumerprices
Moneysupply
Source:AfricanDevelopmentBankSocioEconomicDatabase,1960–2022,/nbyenxf/afdb-socio-economic-database-1960-2022#
Inaddition,thegrowthrateofthemoneysupplywasquitehighduringtheglobalfinancialcrisis.Agrowthrateofapproximately20%from2006to2009wasmaintained.Finally,weobserve
counter-cyclicalmonetarypolicyduringtheEbolacrisis.Followingthesecondcrisisassociatedwiththepresidentialelection,expansionarymonetarypolicycausedlargeincreasesininflation.Duringthefinancialcrisis,alargeincreaseintheinflationratecouldalsobeobserved.Inlateryears,inflationappearstohavebeenbettermanagedwithexpansionarymonetarypolicynot
11MacroeconomicResilienceinBeninandTogo
leadingtolargeincreasesininflation.However,thistrendappearstohavebeenbrokenfollowingtheCOVID-19pandemic(notshowninthefigure).In2022,inflationreached7.6%followingtheexpansionarymonetarypolicyduringtheCOVID-19crisis.12
12InternationalMonetaryFund,‘InflationRate,AverageConsumerPrices’,/external/datamapper/PCPIPCH@WEO/
温馨提示
- 1. 本站所有资源如无特殊说明，都需要本地电脑安装OFFICE2007和PDF阅读器。图纸软件为CAD,CAXA,PROE,UG,SolidWorks等.压缩文件请下载最新的WinRAR软件解压。
- 2. 本站的文档不包含任何第三方提供的附件图纸等，如果需要附件，请联系上传者。文件的所有权益归上传用户所有。
- 3. 本站RAR压缩包中若带图纸，网页内容里面会有图纸预览，若没有图纸预览就没有图纸。
- 4. 未经权益所有人同意不得将文件中的内容挪作商业或盈利用途。
- 5. 人人文库网仅提供信息存储空间，仅对用户上传内容的表现方式做保护处理，对用户上传分享的文档内容本身不做任何修改或编辑，并不能对任何下载内容负责。
- 6. 下载文件中如有侵权或不适当内容，请与我们联系，我们立即纠正。
- 7. 本站不保证下载资源的准确性、安全性和完整性, 同时也不承担用户因使用这些下载资源对自己和他人造成任何形式的伤害或损失。
最新文档
- 职业培训学校招生管理制度
- 老年人活动中心国庆节联欢方案
- 2024年工厂技术研发合作协议
- 高聚物合金2023学习通超星期末考试答案章节答案2024年
- 艺术展览馆拆除工程实施方案
- 城市轨道交通票务系统优化方案
- 2024年工保指南：工程履约担保条款解析
- 2024年小额贷款转让合同样本
- 变电站接地材料采购方案
- 酒店行业总经理岗位聘任协议书
- 公务员2021年国考《申论》真题（地市级）及参考答案
- 新教科版小学1-6年级科学需做实验目录
- 2024秋期国家开放大学专科《高等数学基础》一平台在线形考(形考任务一至四)试题及答案
- DPtech-FW1000系列防火墙系统操作手册
- 图像学完整分
- 印刷服务投标方案（技术方案）
- 思想道德与法治课件：第五章 第二节 吸收借鉴优秀道德成果
- 西安作文800字
- (完整版)小学英语教师个人专业发展规划(最新整理)
- 初级养老护理员培训全套ppt课件ppt
- 物理化学-傅献彩-第八章-电解质溶液ppt课件
评论
0/150
提交评论