c标-789d2外墙涂料评标报告

1、橡树湾（厦门）项目一期 C 标段仿石涂料、多彩漆、普通外墙涂料供应及安装工程评 标橡树湾（厦门）项目一期 C 标段仿石涂料、多彩漆、普通外墙涂料供应及安装工程 经评标小组对各投标人的商务、技术综合评定及洽商，建议由 世纪建筑装饰中标本工程，中标价 ￥8,842,983.61 元（方案组合）。详细评审如下：一、投标本形式为邀请招标，共向 4 家发出招标文件，4 家在投标截止日前回标，经开标核实，投标资料有效，此 4 家投标人为：市特艺达建筑装饰工程（简称“特艺达” ）厦门装饰材料（简称“” ）福建六建（简称“六建” ）世鳄建筑装饰（简称“世鳄” ）二、招标过程2013 年 1 月3 月，厂家收集

2、，样板制作及筛选，合格样品上墙工艺展示；2013 年 3 月 29 日发标；2013 年 4 月 10 日回标；2013 年 4 月 10 日开标；2013 年 4 月 11 号商务洽商；2013 年 4 月 15 号开定标会；三商务标分析1）、投标人分别按招标要求提供了报价，四家投标人的方案一（仿石涂料、多彩漆做法含抗裂砂浆及耐碱网格布）；方案二（仿石涂料、多彩漆做法不含抗裂砂浆及耐碱网格布）；方案三（仿石涂料、多彩漆做法不含耐水腻子）报价对比如下：细项报价如下：项目工程量世鳄单价世鳄合价特艺达单价特艺达合价六建单价六建合价单价合价方案一汇总9963724.1810612010.311120

3、7827.8011319793.09第一章开办项目30000.0050000400000.00第二章小结9028724.189752010.3110267827.8011060166.35深褐色多彩漆11313.37m2111.461260988.22125.91424353.28139.721580704.06127.61443586.01深黄色仿石涂料79000m292.337294070.0098.497780710.00102.648108560.00114.919077890.00普通外墙涂料8944.98m234.15305471.0739.43352700.5641.343697

4、85.4736.56327028.47深黄色外墙腻子5362.15m212.8568903.6314.5277858.4215.281504.6821.34114428.28深黄色质感涂料1387.86m259.6882827.4868.1294541.0277.73107878.3667.493541.76EPS 造型板100.98m2163.0416463.78216.3521847.02192.0719395.2336.563691.83第三章选择性项目小结905000.00810000.00900000.00259626.74多彩漆吊篮费用11313.37m210.02905000.0

5、08.97810000.009.97900000.00222626.74仿石涂料吊篮费用79000m23237000.00项目工程量世鳄单价世鳄合价特艺达单价特艺达合价六建单价六建合价单价合价序号投标人世鳄合价特艺达合价六建合价合价1方案一汇总（元）9963724.1810612010.3111207827.8011319793.092高于(元）0.00648286.131244103.621356068.923高于百分比0.00%6.51%12.49%13.61%1方案二汇总9400086.5910126606.8010246893.549658417.912高于(元）0.00726520.

6、21846806.95258331.313高于百分比0.00%7.73%9.01%2.75%1方案三汇总9404147.7910063387.4410238398.8310348962.002高于(元）0.00659239.66834251.04944814.213高于百分比0.00%7.01%8.87%10.05%方案二汇总9400086.5910126606.8010246893.549658417.91第一章开办项目30000.0050000400000.00第二章小结8465086.599266606.809306893.549398791.17深褐色多彩漆11313.37m2106.

7、331202950.63117.561329999.78129.081460329.80115.171302960.82深黄色仿石涂料79000m285.936788470.0093.547389660.00927268000.0095.667557140.00普通外墙涂料8944.98m234.15305471.0739.43352700.5641.34369785.4736.56327028.47深黄色外墙腻子5362.15m212.8568903.6314.5277858.4215.281504.6821.34114428.28深黄色质感涂料1387.86m259.6882827.486

8、8.1294541.0277.73107878.3667.493541.76EPS 造型板100.98m2163.0416463.78216.3521847.02192.0719395.2336.563691.83第三章选择性项目小结905000.00810000.00900000.00259626.74多彩漆吊篮费用11313.37m210.02905000.008.97810000.009.97900000.00222626.74仿石涂料吊篮费用79000m23237000.00方案三汇总9404147.7910063387.4410238398.8310348962.00第一章开办项目3

9、0000.0050000400000.00第二章小结8469147.799203387.449298398.8310089335.26深褐色多彩漆11313.37m2106.271202271.83116.861322080.42127.981447885.09114.131291194.92深黄色仿石涂料79000m285.996793210.0092.847334360.0092.057271950.00104.558259450.00普通外墙涂料8944.98m234.15305471.0739.43352700.5641.34369785.4736.56327028.47深黄色外墙腻子

10、5362.15m212.8568903.6314.5277858.4215.281504.6821.34114428.28深黄色质感涂料1387.86m259.6882827.4868.1294541.0277.73107878.3667.493541.76EPS 造型板100.98m2163.0416463.78216.3521847.02192.0719395.2336.563691.83第三章选择性项目小结905000.00810000.00900000.00259626.74多彩漆吊篮费用11313.37m210.02905000.008.97810000.009.97900000.0

11、0222626.74仿石涂料吊篮费用79000m23237000.00商务标为：方案一、方案三：1、世鳄；2、特艺达；3、六建；4、。方案二：1、世鳄；2、；3、特艺达；4、六建。经以上对比，世鳄报价最低，其真石漆（方案二）报价低于B 标段合同价约 5%，主要为材料价格降低，人工略有上浮，符合目前市场行情，属合理报价，但其吊篮及 EPS 造型板报价偏高，需进一步澄清。四、技术标评比技术标：1、世见（项目部）；鳄；2、；3、特艺达；4、六建。（详见外墙涂料技术评标意小样品及上墙工艺评比：世鳄样板与B 标一致，符合性最好；（SKK）、特艺达（卡普乐尔）、六建（克）的样板与 B 标略微有差异，但基本

12、符合。（详见厦门橡树湾 C 标段外墙涂料评标-设计部）；五、商务洽商根据商务及技术分析，世鳄均第一，但其报价中仍有部分报价不合理，评标小组于 4月 11 日与其进行商务洽商，要求其调整不合理项。经第一次质询后，世鳄调整单价，其中深黄色质感涂料单价调整为 55 元/平米，EPS 单价调整为 80 元/平米，选择性项目吊篮费用调整为 30 万元包干，调整后商务标不变，对比如下（洽商详工程采购洽商会议表）：品牌对比如下：序号项目世鳄特艺达六建1外墙腻子、深黄色涂料底漆龙卡谱乐尔克SKK2深黄色质感涂料、普通外墙涂料龙卡谱乐尔克SKK3EPS 造型板索利特-4多彩漆、仿石涂料鳄鱼卡谱乐尔克SKK修正报

13、价后对比投标人世鳄修正报价后合价特艺达合价六建合价合价方案一汇总（元）9343843.6110612010.3111207827.8011319793.09高于(元）0.001268166.691863984.181975949.48高于百分比0.00%13.57%19.95%21.15%方案二汇总8780206.0310126606.8010246893.549658417.91高于(元）0.001346400.781466687.51878211.88高于百分比0.00%15.33%16.70%10.00%方案三汇总8784267.2210063387.4410238398.8310348

14、962.00高于(元）0.001279120.221454131.611564694.78高于百分比0.00%14.56%16.55%17.81%质询后细项对比如下：项目工程量第一次质询后世鳄单价第一次质询后世鳄合价特艺达单价特艺达合价六建单价六建合价单价合价方案一汇总9343843.6110612010.3111207827.8011319793.09第一章开办项目30000.0050000400000.00第二章小结9013843.619752010.3110267827.8011060166.35深褐色多彩漆11313.37m2111.461260988.22125.91424353.2

15、8139.721580704.06127.61443586.01深黄色仿石涂料79000m292.337294070.0098.497780710.00102.648108560.00114.919077890.00普通外墙涂料8944.98m234.15305471.0739.43352700.5641.34369785.4736.56327028.47深黄色外墙腻子5362.15m212.8568903.6314.5277858.4215.281504.6821.34114428.28深黄色质感涂料1387.86m25576332.3068.1294541.0277.73107878.36

16、67.493541.76EPS 造型板100.98m2808078.40216.3521847.02192.0719395.2336.563691.83第三章选择性项目小结300000.00810000.00900000.00259626.74多彩漆吊篮费用11313.37m23.32300000.008.97810000.009.97900000.00222626.74仿石涂料吊篮费用79000m23237000.00方案二汇总8780206.0310126606.8010246893.549658417.91第一章开办项目30000.0050000400000.00第二章小结8450206

17、.039266606.809306893.549398791.17深褐色多彩漆11313.37m2106.331202950.63117.561329999.78129.081460329.80115.171302960.82深黄色仿石涂料79000m285.936788470.0093.547389660.00927268000.0095.667557140.00普通外墙涂料8944.98m234.15305471.0739.43352700.5641.34369785.4736.56327028.47深黄色外墙腻子5362.15m212.8568903.6314.5277858.4215.

18、281504.6821.34114428.28深黄色质感涂料1387.86m25576332.3068.1294541.0277.73107878.3667.493541.76EPS 造型板100.98m2808078.40216.3521847.02192.0719395.2336.563691.83第三章选择性项目小结300000.00810000.00900000.00259626.74多彩漆吊篮费用11313.37m23.32300000.008.97810000.009.97900000.00222626.74仿石涂料吊篮费用79000m23237000.00方案三汇总8784267

19、.2210063387.4410238398.8310348962.00第一章开办项目30000.0050000400000.00第二章小结8454267.229203387.449298398.8310089335.26深褐色多彩漆11313.37m2106.271202271.83116.861322080.42127.981447885.09114.131291194.92深黄色仿石涂料79000m285.996793210.0092.847334360.0092.057271950.00104.558259450.00普通外墙涂料8944.98m234.15305471.0739.43352700.5641.34369785.4736.56327028.47深黄色外墙腻子5362.15m212.8568903.6314.5277858.4215.281504.6821.34114428.28深黄色质感涂料1387.86m25576332.3068.1294541.0277.73107878.3667.493541.76EPS 造型板100.98m2808078.40216.3521847.02192.0719395.2336.563691.83第三章选择性项目小结300000.00810000.009000