版权说明:本文档由用户提供并上传,收益归属内容提供方,若内容存在侵权,请进行举报或认领
文档简介
JUNE 2021
LAZARD’SLEVELIZEDCOSTOFHYDROGENANALYSIS
LAZARD’S LEVELIZED COST OF HYDROGEN ANALYSIS
Lazard’sLevelizedCostofHydrogenAnalysis—ExecutiveSummary
Overviewof
Analysis
OverviewofHydrogenProductionandApplications
CostAnalysis
LazardhasundertakenananalysisoftheLevelizedCostofHydrogen(“LCOH”)inanefforttoprovidegreaterclaritytoIndustryparticipantsonthepotentiallydisruptiveroleofhydrogenacrossavarietyofeconomicsectors.OurLCOHbuildsupon,andrelatesto,ourannualLevelizedCostofEnergy(“LCOE”)andLevelizedCostofStorage(“LCOS”)studies.Giventhisbreadth,wehavedecidedtofocustheanalysisonthefollowingkeytopics:
Anoverviewofthevariousmethodsforproducinghydrogenandvariousapplicationsofhydrogenacrosseconomicsectors
AdiscussionofFAQspertainingtohydrogengivenitsrelativelynascentpresenceacrossmosteconomicsectors
Alevelizedcostanalysisofgreenhydrogen(i.e.,hydrogenproducedusingwaterandrenewableenergy)basedontwoprimaryelectrolyzertechnologiesandanillustrativesetofelectrolyzercapacities
OuranalysisintentionallyfocusesonakeysubsetofassumptionsforcalculatingtheLCOH.Theadditionalfactorslistedbelowhavebeenintentionallyexcludedbutwouldalsohaveanimpactonthedeliveredcostofgreenhydrogen:
Conversiontootherstatesand/oradditionalpurificationfortheproductionofotherchemicals(i.e.,liquefaction,productionofammonia,methanol,etc.)
Compressionand/orstoragecosts,whetheron-oroff-site
Transmission,distributionandtransportationcosts(e.g.,pipeline,truck,ship,etc.)
Additionalinvestmentand/orretrofittingofend-useinfrastructure/equipmentfortheuseofhydrogenvs.theoriginalfuelsource
Hydrogeniscurrentlyproducedprimarilyfromfossilfuelsusingsteam-methanereformingandmethanesplittingprocesses(i.e.,“gray”hydrogen)
Avarietyofadditionalprocessesareavailabletoproducehydrogenfromelectricityandwater,whichareatvaryingdegreesofdevelopmentandcommercialviability
Givenitsversatilityasanenergycarrier,hydrogenhasthepotentialtobeusedacrossindustrialprocesses,powergenerationandtransportation,creatingapotentialpathfordecarbonizingenergy-intensiveindustrieswherecurrenttechnologies/alternativesarenotpresentlyviable
Greenhydrogeniscurrentlymoreexpensivethantheconventionalfuelsorhydrogenitwoulddisplace—theintentofthiscostanalysisistobenchmarktheLCOHofgreenhydrogenona$/kgbasissuchthatreadersmayconverttotheequivalentcostofagivenenduseofinterest(e.g.,asfeedstockforammoniaproduction,displacingnaturalgasinapowerplant,etc.)
Applicationswhichrequireminimaladditionalsteps(e.g.,conversion,storage,transportation,etc.)toreachtheenduserwillachievecostcompetitivenesssoonerthanthosethatdonot
Thisdynamicisfurtheramplifiedtotheextentthatendusesrequireretrofittingequipmenttoutilizehydrogenvs.theconventionalalternatives
Electricityrepresents~30%–60%ofthecosttoproducehydrogenfromelectrolyzerswithacapacityof20+MW—theLCOHisthereforehighlydependentonthecostoftheavailablesourcesofelectricity
Thenext-mostsignificantdriveroftheLCOHisthecostoftheelectrolyzer,whichisexpectedtodecreaseasaresultofrapidgrowthinindustryscaleandtechnologicaladvancement
Inassessingthecostprofileofgreenhydrogen,therelativecostpositionofgreenhydrogenascomparedtoconventionalfuelsorgrayhydrogenisanobviouscorecomponentoftheanalysisasistherelevantusecasebeingcompared
Acostofcarbon,oravoidanceofsuchcosts,isnotincludedintheLCOHnoraregovernmentsupportmechanisms—bothofthesefactorscouldbeimpactfultoanycost/projectanalysis
Note:
Lazard’sLCOHanalysisisconductedwithsupportfromRolandBerger.Thisanalysisisillustrativeinnatureandshouldnotbeconsideredasabenchmarkforanygivenproject.
1
Copyright2021Lazard
Thisanalysisshouldnotbeconsideredasabasisfromwhichtomakeinvestment,regulatoryorstrategicdecisionsorotherwise.
ThisstudyhasbeenpreparedbyLazardforgeneralinformationalpurposesonly,anditisnotintendedtobe,andshouldnotbeconstruedas,financialorotheradvice.Nopartofthismaterialmaybecopied,photocopiedorduplicatedinanyformbyanymeansorredistributedwithoutthepriorconsentofLazard.
I OverviewofHydrogenProductionandApplications
I OVERVIEW OF HYDROGEN PRODUCTION AND APPLICATIONS
LeadingProcessesforHydrogenProduction
Hydrogenhashistoricallybeenproducedprimarilythroughtheuseoffossilfuels;however,improvementsinthecosteffectivenessofrenewableenergyandelectrolyzertechnologycreateapathforeconomicallyviablegreenhydrogen
ByproductsProcessFeedstock
FossilFuels
NuclearEnergy
Water(H2O)
Water(H2O)
Thermochemical
High-Temperature
Steam-Methane
MethaneSplitting
Reforming
Splitting
SteamElectrolysis
CarbonDioxide
(CO2)Capture
andStorage
CarbonDioxide
Carbon
Oxygen(O2)
Oxygen(O2)
(CO2)
Monoxide(CO)
GrayHydrogen
BlueHydrogen
Yellow
Hydrogen
Notes
Notes
Renewable
Energy
Water(H2O)
Low-Temperature
Electrolysis
Oxygen(O2)
GreenHydrogen
Notes
Steamreforminginvolvesinjectingsteamintonaturalgas,producing“gray”hydrogenandCO2
SubsequentCO2captureandstorageproduces“blue”hydrogen
Methanesplittingutilizesahigh-temperatureplasmatosplitnaturalgasinto“blue”hydrogenandcarbonmonoxide
Thermochemicalsplittingutilizesahigh-temperatureprocesstoproduce“yellow”hydrogenandoxygen
High-temperaturesteamelectrolysisutilizesanelectriccurrentandhigh-temperaturesteamtoproduce“yellow”hydrogenandoxygen
Low-temperatureelectrolysisisanelectrochemicalprocessinwhichacurrentisappliedtowatertoproducegreenhydrogenandoxygen
Alkalineandpolymerelectrolytemembrane(“PEM”)electrolyzersarecurrentlytheprimarytechnologiesutilizedforlow-
temperatureelectrolysis
2
Copyright2021Lazard Source:WorldNuclearAssociation(2020),HydrogenCouncil,InternationalEnergyAgency,FuelCellandHydrogenEnergyAssociationandNationalRenewableEnergyLaboratory.
ThisstudyhasbeenpreparedbyLazardforgeneralinformationalpurposesonly,anditisnotintendedtobe,andshouldnotbeconstruedas,financialorotheradvice.Nopartofthismaterialmaybecopied,photocopiedorduplicatedinanyformbyanymeansorredistributedwithoutthepriorconsentofLazard.
I OVERVIEW OF HYDROGEN PRODUCTION AND APPLICATIONS
HydrogenApplicationsinToday’sEconomy
Theadaptabilityofhydrogentosupplementorreplacegaseousandliquidfossilfuelscreatesnumerousopportunitiestoaddresstheneedsofavarietyofeconomicsectors
Form
Sector
Power
GasDistribution/DistrictHeating
GAS&
OilandGasProduction
FUELCELL
Heavy/SpecialtyIndustry
IndustrialChemicalProduction
Heavy-Duty/IndustrialVehicles
H2
GAS&
Cargoand/orPassengerRail
FUELCELL
MaritimeShippingand/orTravel
Aviation
GAS&LIQUID/
Light-DutyVehicles
SYNTHETICFUEL
Other
Notes
Gaseoushydrogenandammoniacanbeutilizedasfuelsubstitutesinpowergeneration,gasdistribution,andcombinedheatandpower(“CHP”)applications
Hydrogencouldalsoprovideameansforprovidingseasonalstorageforthepowergrid
Hydrogenisusedinrefiningandcanbeintegratedintotheproductionprocessesforcarbon-intensivematerialssuchasaluminum,iron,steelandcement
Theproductionofammonia,methanolandotherindustrialchemicalsrequireshydrogenasaprimaryingredient
Gaseoushydrogencanbecombusteddirectly,orwhenpairedwithfuelcells,canfunctionasasubstituteforconventionalfuels(e.g.,naturalgas,fueloil,etc.)foruseincommercialandindustrialvehicles(e.g.,forklifts,etc.)
Hydrogenfuelcellelectricvehicles(“HFEVs”)competefavorablywithbatteryelectricvehicles(“BEVs”)inindustrialapplicationsthatrequirehighuptime,quickrefuelingandtheabilitytomoveheavyloads
Ammoniaandmethanolareviablesubstitutefuelsforvariousheavy-dutyapplications(e.g.,maritime),wheretheenergydensityandeaseofhandlingofthesefuelsiscompetitivewithconventionalalternatives
Hydrogencanbecombinedwithcarbondioxidetoproducelow-ornet-zeroemissionsaviationandsyntheticfuels,dependingontheinitialsourceofcarbondioxide
HFEVsareaviablealternativetoBEVsforlarger/heavierpassengervehicles(e.g.,sportutilityvehicles),wheretheadditionalcarryingcapacityoffueloffsetstherelativelyheaviervehicleplatform
HFEVsmaintainanadvantageoverBEVstotheextenttheweight-to-powerdensityprofileoflargerpassengervehiclesoffsetsthelowerefficiencyofthegas-to-electricity
conversionprocess
3
Copyright2021Lazard Source:HydrogenCouncil,InternationalEnergyAgency,FuelCellandHydrogenEnergyAssociationandNationalRenewableEnergyLaboratory.
ThisstudyhasbeenpreparedbyLazardforgeneralinformationalpurposesonly,anditisnotintendedtobe,andshouldnotbeconstruedas,financialorotheradvice.Nopartofthismaterialmaybecopied,photocopiedorduplicatedinanyformbyanymeansorredistributedwithoutthepriorconsentofLazard.
II FrequentlyAskedQuestionsPertainingtoHydrogen
II FREQUENTLY ASKED QUESTIONS PERTAINING TO HYDROGEN
HydrogenFAQs—MarketDrivers
LazardhasundertakenastudyoftheLCOHtoanalyzethecurrentunsubsidizedcosttoproducegreenhydrogenthroughelectrolysis.Givenhydrogen’sversatilityasacleanfuelsource,itisviewedasapotentiallydisruptivesolutionfordecarbonizingavarietyofeconomicsectors
WhatIsGreenHydrogenandHowCanItSupporttheDecarbonizationofEconomicActivity?
HowIsGreenHydrogenProduced?
Greenhydrogenisproducedwhenrenewableenergyisusedtosplitwaterintoitscomponentpartsthroughelectrolysis
Theversatilityofgreenhydrogenasaliquidorgaseousfuel,combinedwithitssuitabilityforvariousmodesoftransport,makesitanaturalsubstituteforanumberofexistingfossilfuels(e.g.,naturalgas,gasoline,diesel,coalandoil)
Asaresultofitsversatility,greenhydrogenisapotentialsolutionforreducingcarbonemissionsintraditionally“hard-to-abate”sectorssuchastransportation/mobility,heating,oilrefining,ammoniaandmethanolproduction,andpowergeneration
Therearefourtypesofwaterelectrolysistechnologiesthatareusedtocreategreenhydrogen:
Alkalineelectrolysisisthemostdevelopedandcommercializedprocesstodate
PEMelectrolysisisthenext-mostmatureprocesswithgrowingcommercialization
PEMisadvantageousoveralkalinewithasmallerfootprint,abilitytoloadfollowduetolowerstartupandsystemresponsetimes,lowerminimumloadrequirementsandgreaterloadflexibility(i.e.,optimizeoutputbasedontheavailabilityofintermittentrenewableenergy)
Solidoxideandanionexchangemembrane(“AEM”)electrolysisprocessesarestillinpilot/developmentstages—theseprocessesarenotexpectedtobebroadlycommercializedbeforethemid2020s
Source:InternationalRenewableEnergyAgency,InternationalEnergyAgency,U.S.DepartmentofEnergy,BidenAdministration,EuropeanUnion,nationalgovernmentfilings,National
4
Copyright2021Lazard
RenewableEnergyLaboratoryandCaliforniaEnergyCommission.
ThisstudyhasbeenpreparedbyLazardforgeneralinformationalpurposesonly,anditisnotintendedtobe,andshouldnotbeconstruedas,financialor
otheradvice.Nopartofthismaterialmaybecopied,photocopiedorduplicatedinanyformbyanymeansorredistributedwithoutthepriorconsentofLazard.
II FREQUENTLY ASKED QUESTIONS PERTAINING TO HYDROGEN
HydrogenFAQs—End-UseApplications
Hydrogeniscurrentlyusedprimarilyinindustrialapplications,includingoilrefining,steelproduction,ammoniaandmethanolproduction,andfeedstockforothersmaller-scalechemicalprocesses
WhichSectorsCan
GreenhydrogenisbestpositionedtoreduceCO2emissionsintypically“hard-to-abate”sectorssuchascementproduction,
UtilizeGreen
centralizedenergysystems,steelproduction,transportationandmobility(e.g.,forklifts,maritimevessels,trucksandbuses),
HydrogentoReduce
andbuildingpowerandheatsystems
CO2Emissions?
Naturalgasutilitiesarelikelytobeearlyadoptersofgreenhydrogenasmethanation(i.e.,combininghydrogenwithCO2to
producemethane)becomescommerciallyviableandpipelineinfrastructureisupgradedtosupporthydrogenblends
WhatIsthe
Materialhandlingequipment(e.g.,forklifts)andindustrialusecases(e.g.,oilrefining,ammoniaandmethanolfeedstock)are
currentlyamongthemorewidelyadoptedusecasesforgreenhydrogen
“Integration
Near-term(asthedecadeprogresses),“massmarketacceptability”(i.e.,sales>1%ofthemarket)couldoccurfor
Readiness”ofVarious
applicationssuchasheavy-dutytrucking,citybuses,decarbonizationoffeedstockandhydrogenstorage,amongothers
UseCaseswith
RespecttoGreenH2?
Longer-term(i.e.,beyond2030),commerciallyviablegreenhydrogenapplicationsareexpectedtoexpandtoothermobility
segments(e.g.,drop-insyntheticfuels),steelproduction,blendingwithnaturalgasandheatingapplications
Potentialinfrastructureneedsforthewidespreadadoptionofgreenhydrogen:
Oncegreenhydrogenisproduced,itmustbestored,transportedandpotentiallyconverted,unlessconsumedon-site
Transportandstorage(e.g.,pressurization)aremeaningfulbarriersforgreenhydrogenbeingbroadlycostcompetitive
Mostexistingnaturalgasdistributioninfrastructurecannotaccommodatepureorevenlow-levelblending(i.e.,<20%)of
hydrogenwithnaturalgas
WhatInfrastructure
Refuelingstationsformobilityapplicationswillrequiresophisticatedstoragefacilitiesandeitherlocalordistributed
IsNeededtoSupport
production,withthelatternecessitatingtransmissioninfrastructurefromcentralproductionlocations
Adoption?
Certainexistinginfrastructurecanbeutilizedtosupportthewidespreadadoptionofgreenhydrogen
Injectionofhydrogenintoexistingindustrial(i.e.,welded)pipelineinfrastructureisacost-effectivemeansfortransportationanddistribution
Non-pipelinetransportation(e.g.,shipping,trucking,etc.)issubstantiallymoreexpensive,albeitfacilitateslonger-rangeandmoreflexibletransportation
Methanatedgreenhydrogen(i.e.,greenmethane)isfullycompatiblewithexistingnaturalgasdistributioninfrastructure
Source:Companyfilings,HydrogenCouncil,InternationalEnergyAgency,InternationalRenewableEnergyAgency,FuelCellandHydrogenEnergyAssociation,U.S.
5
Copyright2021Lazard
DepartmentofEnergyandNationalRenewableEnergyLaboratory.
ThisstudyhasbeenpreparedbyLazardforgeneralinformationalpurposesonly,anditisnotintendedtobe,andshouldnotbeconstruedas,financialor
otheradvice.Nopartofthismaterialmaybecopied,photocopiedorduplicatedinanyformbyanymeansorredistributedwithoutthepriorconsentofLazard.
II FREQUENTLY ASKED QUESTIONS PERTAINING TO HYDROGEN
HydrogenFAQs—IndustryLandscape
WhatIstheGreenHydrogenValueChainandWhoAretheKeyPlayers?
Thegreenhydrogenproductionvaluechaincanbedividedintofiveprimarysegments:
Processinputgeneration
Greenhydrogenproduction
Conversion,includingcompressionandstorage
Transportation,includingvesselsandpipeline
Reconversiontogaseoushydrogenasapplicable
Keyendusersinthevaluechainincludeindependentpowerproducers,electricandnaturalgasutilities,oilandgasmajors,electrolyzermanufacturers,theautomotivesector,infrastructureandtransportationproviders,andotherendusers
Theelectrolyzermanufacturerlandscapeissplitbetweenadvancedmanufacturersandsmallerplayerswhosetechnologiesarestillunderdevelopmentorinpilotstages
Downstreamvaluechainparticipantsincludeutilities,oilandgasmajors,transportandstorageprovidersincludingfuelcells,andvariousmunicipalities/governmentsandOEMsdrivingrefuelingstationinvestment
Source:Companyfilings,U.S.DepartmentofEnergy,HydrogenCouncil,InternationalEnergyAgency,FuelCellandHydrogenEnergyAssociationandNational
6
Copyright2021Lazard
RenewableEnergyLaboratory.
ThisstudyhasbeenpreparedbyLazardforgeneralinformationalpurposesonly,anditisnotintendedtobe,andshouldnotbeconstruedas,financialor
otheradvice.Nopartofthismaterialmaybecopied,photocopiedorduplicatedinanyformbyanymeansorredistributedwithoutthepriorconsentofLazard.
II FREQUENTLY ASKED QUESTIONS PERTAINING TO HYDROGEN
HydrogenFAQs—CostEffectiveness
Greenhydrogenisnotyetbroadlycostcompetitiveascomparedtotheconventionalfuelsitwouldreplace
Thiscostdisparityshoulddiminishasthecostofrenewableenergycontinuestodeclineand/orgreenhydrogenprojects
WhatIstheCostof
aredevelopedinsuchawayastoconsumerenewableenergythatwouldotherwisebecurtailed
GreenHydrogen
RelativetoOther
Transportation,conversion,andinfrastructureandend-useupgradecostswillcontinuetobemeaningfuldriversofthecost
Fuels?
structureofgreenhydrogenvs.alternativefuels
Otherformsofhydrogen(e.g.,bluehydrogen)arecurrentlylessexpensivethangreenhydrogen,particularlyintheabsence
ofcarbonpricingorothermechanismsusedtoaccountforemissions
Thecostcompetitivenessofgreenhydrogenshouldincreaseastheindustrygrows,drivingimprovementsintheunderlying
electrolyzertechnologyinconjunctionwithcostimprovementsresultingfrommanufacturingscaleandefficiency
WhatWillBetheKey
Electrolyzerstackcostscurrentlycomprise~33%–45%ofthetotalcapitalcostswhilethecostofelectricityrepresents
DriversofGreen
~30%–60%ofthelevelizedcostofgreenhydrogen
HydrogenCost
Policyaction(e.g.,carbonpricesorincentives)shouldalsoinfluencetherelativecostofgreenhydrogenascomparedto
Competitiveness?
fossilfuelalternatives
Thefuturecostcompetitivenessofgreenhydrogenwillalsodependontheinterplaybetweenenduseandproximityof
production,whichinturninformsthetransportationandstoragecostsassociatedwithagivenapplication
Giventhatthecostofelectricityisakeydriverofthecostofgreenhydrogen,theavailabilityoflow-costrenewableenergyiscritical—theoptimallocationsforgreenhydrogenproductioninthisregardwillbeinareasthat:
HowWillRenewableEnergyProductionandLocationImpactCosts?
Havethecapacitytoproducegreenhydrogenatscaleandwithabundantlow-orzero-cost(i.e.,curtailed)renewableenergyresources
Haveinherentdemandforlocalgreenhydrogen(e.g.,drivenbydecarbonizationregulations/incentives)and/orareequippedwithefficienttransportationinfrastructure,therebyavoidinghightransportationandstoragecosts
Source:Companyfilings,HydrogenCouncil,InternationalEnergyAgency,InternationalRenewableEnergyAgency,FuelCellandHydrogenEnergyAssociation,
7
Copyright2021Lazard
CaliforniaEnergyCommissionandNationalRenewableEnergyLaboratory.
ThisstudyhasbeenpreparedbyLazardforgeneralinformationalpurposesonly,anditisnotintendedtobe,andshouldnotbeconstruedas,financialor
otheradvice.Nopartofthismaterialmaybecopied,photocopiedorduplicatedinanyformbyanymeansorredistributedwithoutthepriorconsentofLazard.
III IllustrativeGreenHydrogenCostAnalysis
III ILLUSTRATIVE GREEN HYDROGEN COST ANALYSIS
Lazard’sLevelizedCostofHydrogen—Methodology
Lazard’sLevelizedCostofHydrogenanalysisisillustrativeinnatureandemploysasimplifiedmethodology.Asaresult,anumberofassumptionsmustbemadetostandardizethevariousparametersofanotherwisecomplexanalysis,including:
TheLCOHiscalculated“asdelivered”byanAlkalineorPEMelectrolyzer—noadditionalconversion,storageortransportationcostsareconsideredinthisanalysis
Theelectricityutilizedasaninputforelectrolysisisproducedbyarenewableenergyfacility,therebymakingthehydrogen“green”—thepotentialintermittencyoftherenewableenergyresourceiscapturedintheutilizationassumptionwhichissensitizedinthesubsequentpages
Theanalysishorizonis15years.Inputcostsaregrownbyafixedescalationrateoverthisterm—seepagetitled,“LevelizedCostofHydrogen—KeyAssumptions”foradditionaldetail
Anavailabilityfactorof98%isassumedacrosstechnologiesandsystemcapacities—adjustmentstoutilizationratesdonotimpacttheoperationalcharacteristics,andassociatedmaintenancecosts,ofaplantbeyondtheconsumptionofinputsandresultinghydrogenproduced
Stackreplacementoccursatanintervaldeterminedbyplantavailability,utilizationandstacklifetime(measuredinhours)—stackreplacementcostsareidenticaltotheoriginalcostofthestack
Thisanalysiscalculatestherevenuerequirement,ona$/kgbasis,neededtoachievea12%levered,after-taxreturntotheprojectinvestor.Seepagetitled,“LevelizedCostofHydrogen—KeyAssumptions”foradditionaldetailsonassumedcapitalstructure
Otherfactorswouldalsohaveapotentiallysignificanteffectontheresultscontainedherein,buthavenotbeenexaminedinthescopeofthisanalysis.Theseadditionalfactors,amongothers,couldinclude:developmentcostsoftheelectrolyzerandassociatedrenewableenergygenerationfacility;conversion,storageortransportationcostsofthehydrogenonceproduced;additionalcoststoproducealternatefuels(e.g.,ammonia);coststoupgradeexistinginfrastructuretofacilitatethetransportationofhydrogen(e.g.,naturalgasdistributionpipelines);electricalgridupgrades;costsassociatedwithmodifyingend-useinfrastructure/equipmenttousehydrogenasafuelsource;potentialvalueassociatedwithcarbon-freefuelproduction(e.g.,carboncredits,incentives,etc.).Thisanalysisalsodoesnotaddresspotentialenvironmentalandsocialexternalities,including,forexample,waterconsumptionandthesocietalconsequencesofdisplacingthevariousconventionalfuelswithhydrogenthataredifficulttomeasure
8
Copyright2021Lazard
Note:Seepagetitled,“LevelizedCostofHydrogen—KeyAssumptions”fordetailedmodelingassumptionsforallprojecttypesevaluatedinthisanalysis.
ThisstudyhasbeenpreparedbyLazardforgeneralinformationalpurposesonly,anditisnotintendedtobe,andshouldnotbeconstruedas,financialorotheradvice.Nopartofthismaterialmaybecopied,photocopiedorduplicatedinanyformbyanymeansorredistributedwithoutthepriorconsentofLazard.
III ILLUSTRATIVE GREEN HYDROGEN COST ANALYSIS
CurrentLevelizedCostofHydrogenProduction(1)—1MWElectrolyzer
Greenhydrogenisarelativelyexpensivefuelascomparedtoconventionalalternatives;however,theincreasingpenetrationofrenewableenergyinpowergeneration,technologicalandcostimprovementsinelectrolyzertechnology,andcarbonpricingcollectivelyhavethepotentialtosubstantivelyalterthisdynamic
ThisanalysisevaluatesthesensitivityoftheLCOH,in$/kg,tochangesincapex,costofelectricityandelectrolyzerutilization
Wehavecompiledmarketdatafor“low-”,“medium-”and“high-”efficiencyelectrolyzersacrosscapacitiesof1,20and100MW
Thesensitivitiesbelowandonsubsequentpagesevaluatethe“medium-”efficiencyunitsacrossscaleandtechnology
SensitivitytoElectricityCostandElectrolyzerCapex(2)
($/MWh)EnergyCost
Alkaline(1MW)
ElectrolyzerCapex($/kW)
$/kg
$1,180
$1,310
$1,460
$1,610
$1,770
$10
$1.33
$1.43
$1.54
$1.65
$1.77
$20
$1.60
$1.70
$1.81
$1.92
$2.04
$30
$1.87
$1.97
$2.08
$2.19
$2.31
$40
$2.14
$2.24
$2.35
$2.46
$2.57
$50
$2.41
$2.51
$2.62
$2.73
$2.84
($/MWh)EnergyCost
PEM(1MW)
ElectrolyzerCapex($/kW)
$/kg
$1,420
$1,580
$1,760
$1,940
$2,130
$10
$1.84
$1.97
$2.12
$2.27
$2.43
$20
$2.15
$2.28
$2.43
$2.58
$2.74
$30
$2.45
$2.59
$2.74
$2.89
$3.05
$40
$2.76
$2.90
$3.05
$3.20
$3.36
$50
$3.07
$3.21
$3.36
$3.51
$3.67
$/kg
EnergyCost($/MWh)
$10
$20
$40
$30
$50
Copyright2021Lazard
SensitivitytoElectricityCostandUtilizationRate(3)
Alkaline(1MW)
PEM(1MW)
ElectrolyzerUtilization
ElectrolyzerUtilization
100%
90%
80%
70%
60%
$/kg
100%
90%
80%
70%
60%
$1.54
$1.61
$1.76
$1.93
$2.16
EnergyCost($/MWh)
$10
$2.12
$2.25
$2.39
$2.65
$2.98
$1.81
$1.88
$2.03
$2.20
$2.43
$20
$2.43
$2.56
$2.70
$2.96
$3.29
$2.35
$2.42
$2.57
$2.74
$2.97
$40
$3.05
$3.18
$3.32
$3.58
$3.90
$2.08
$2.15
$2.30
$2.47
$2.70
$30
$2.74
$2.87
$3.01
$3.27
$3.59
$2.62
$2.69
$2.84
$3.01
$3.24
$50
$3.36
$3.49
$3.63
$3.89
$4.21
Source:FuelCellandHydrogenEnergyAssociation,NationalRenewableEnergyLaboratory,PacificNorthwestNationalLaboratory,andLazardandRolandBergerestimates.
Note:
Seepagetitled,“LevelizedCostofHydrogen—KeyAssumptions”fordetailedmodelingassumptionsforallprojecttypesevaluatedinthisanalysis.
9
(1)
TheLCOHanalysisisbasedondatacollectedfromindustryandadiscountedcashflowanalysiswhichcalculatestherevenuerequirementtoachievealeveredequityreturnof12%.
(2)
Sensitivityisbasedona98%electrolyzerutilizationrateforbothtechnologies.
(3)
Sensitivityisbasedonthecapexassumptionformedium-efficiencyelectrolyzersforeachtechnology.
ThisstudyhasbeenpreparedbyLazardforgeneralinformationalpurposesonly,anditisno
温馨提示
- 1. 本站所有资源如无特殊说明,都需要本地电脑安装OFFICE2007和PDF阅读器。图纸软件为CAD,CAXA,PROE,UG,SolidWorks等.压缩文件请下载最新的WinRAR软件解压。
- 2. 本站的文档不包含任何第三方提供的附件图纸等,如果需要附件,请联系上传者。文件的所有权益归上传用户所有。
- 3. 本站RAR压缩包中若带图纸,网页内容里面会有图纸预览,若没有图纸预览就没有图纸。
- 4. 未经权益所有人同意不得将文件中的内容挪作商业或盈利用途。
- 5. 人人文库网仅提供信息存储空间,仅对用户上传内容的表现方式做保护处理,对用户上传分享的文档内容本身不做任何修改或编辑,并不能对任何下载内容负责。
- 6. 下载文件中如有侵权或不适当内容,请与我们联系,我们立即纠正。
- 7. 本站不保证下载资源的准确性、安全性和完整性, 同时也不承担用户因使用这些下载资源对自己和他人造成任何形式的伤害或损失。
最新文档
- 《Proteus仿真平台单片机项目式教程》课件 项目9 简易电子琴
- 2024年市区国有企业合作协议书范文
- 气温骤变做好防范现在的病症很混杂多加辨别
- 7天双方无责任试岗期协议书范文
- 掌握文学作品背后的历史背景
- 含可燃冰沉积物合成及分解试验规范-编写说明
- 公司级安全培训试题含答案【培优A卷】
- 厂里职工安全培训试题及答案【各地真题】
- 班组三级安全培训试题及答案【夺冠系列】
- 项目部安全培训试题答案可打印
- 小学数学人教六年级上册分数乘法分数乘法第九课时(全国一等奖)
- 陕县赵里河铝土矿矿产资源开采与生态修复方案
- 外送检验服务评分表
- 设计透视学学习
- 无组织废气检测作业指导书
- 钢栈桥施工方案改
- 高中语文 选修中册 第八课时
- 修井作业操作规程完整
- 学校年度师德考核实施方案
- 机械基础教案
- 胰腺囊性病变诊断与鉴别诊断
评论
0/150
提交评论