语法理论习得研究和历时研究方法的完美统一语法竞争模型及其修正

语法理论、习得研究和历时研究方法的完美统一——语法竞争模型及其修正(>o??>??u?C??,>o??,200240)????:?m??????????????,Kroch?Q???4?u??q??m???8?????6?????????v>W?r?????????8????,????>??????????/??,???h??Z?>???????>??y??@,???????v>W?S??????????Z???????,????>?Z??8????>W????????UO??????@,?v????>????u????????Z?????????@(???????8??????@(?????8>&??>??4>????????8?R?.?QZ?????????????,>R???y??????>?????UO??Z???,?mP&P?)???D??Z????4>??7?????????8???3??,>R???y???7Z?>??????)??????>??4,>????m????????>c?????y?????6???2????>?Z?????q*@,>o???????[?m?p?????y??????Z?>P??@,Z??z??:?????????/??,??????>?,?????????8,q???[>W???)????]H04[???z?:???(]A[?????8??]167489212010(07)004107???????8?6??????>???,??>?>o???@?=>?>8????????>&?????????????T@,??????>?>???????????Z?>????u???????8??>??v?C???l,q??????S?)??(AgglutinationTheory)!@(???????l(GrowthPrinciple)!???????8!?Q@,?6?????????????@?????2?????6?8@(?????8@(?????6??@(?P?K????>??T@(Z;??????>???>????????6???R?.?Q(Harris&Campbell1995:1447)@,>??=>8????>o?Y??,?j>?????>f>Q?SUy????Z?????Z????)??????>f???@q*,???????????6???l?:??Z??V,???????????6??>???Z?q>?J@,??20>8??60??>?????,???SLabov?6?????????8??>????9?]??????>8,???????8?6????Z?>?>?>5?W????>?@,???m>??v??>R>?Weinreich,Labov??Herzog(1968)>???????,????????????Z?>??????????.??@,?j?????6???6???????h??,?T?]?????????T>&???t????,>R???????????6??????>??W?????b?@@,Z?q??h??,?m???l>&????(P&P)?)???D??>c,q?>R>??????????v?????????*???l???5???T???8,???8?????k??Z???????,>????j???s????>????9?C???y?????????8@,?h?????????8????>???Z??????????????8,???????8?r??????????>??4??????????Z?????,>??h?7?????????8@,?j??,??>????????8>-????>5???????8,?H>???>?????>?>5???k@(???????4??????????????@,?m????????????>????6??????>W,Kroch??Pintzuk?Q???4?SUy??????q?>f>Q????(variationistapproach)??Z???????!?@,??????????P&P?)??q?q??4??>????7??,>o??>??u?C???8???????????????6???T,?6?????H>R????????????????????????@,?N?U????@j>R???S(??q??m???????8???????8?8???????????C???8),qD?h?????????8?8????(Elanguage)>???Z??8????(Ilanguage)???8?8???????K???6??,?m?6?????c>Wq??m?0?????8???????C????????????,>??????8?8?????????8????,>??hZ??BZ??????6????????@,?????????m>?Z??SUy??????????>??y???h????@,Z?q??h??,?m?????????8?T??,??????>w???????/??Z?>???????(variation)Z????????(,????>R>w?????????????r??,??>w???r???0>???>????(,??Kroch??>x>R??????>?!(GrammarCompetition)(1994)@,>??????)???@Z???>??)????????>???????,?m?????6???6?????????H>??i,>R???????????6??>-????>5???????????6??U?Z?>????????y?z(>c??>W?H>??j?m??????>??y??>?????????,>?Z??BZ?>f???)??????)@,qD?h???m???[?D????Z????????6??????qO,??????>??y???h?J>????m?S>?>?????@,q???,????UO??Z???>?U????m???+?8?.??,???r?mP&P?)???D??Z????4???????8???3??,?)??????>W?R?j??>??4????,?R>q?m?????)???D??>c???v?????6????Z?????q*?Q?Q@,????,??????>??y??>??r????>&??q???,?m???u??????>?q???,>??hq????y??????????@,??>????*??Z??8?u???rZ?????????????????,??>x??Z????M?@???*>R???u???6???4q??m???y??>?>?>????????8???????6??,???H>???Z/?????y????>?>???,?.?&?n???mP&P???)???D??>c,>??????6??????Z???,Z???q*?????y????>?q???,>??Tq?>x?????@?)?)????????????>????????r?R?@??>????K,>R???????8?6????q??r>?UO?????2q???@,#41#?v7?T2010??7?K??>??8???6??No.7July2010:07:1.??????>??y????Kroch(1989)>???,??????>??y?????m>??u???????6??,>?????>?>????9?]??@,?H>??n???mKroch(1989,1994,2001)@(Pintzuk(1999,2003)?Q???6?????S>x>o????????Z?>f??Z???,?h???????????6???????????T?]???????????:Z?Z?>P??>x?0@,1.1??????>??y????>f??Z?????????>??y???????????S?k?????????/??(theConstantRateEffect,CRE)@,Kroch?Q?u???????6??????,?m???????8?T??,>??vqu?h??Z???>w>5???????????r??@,q???,?h>????T?????????v>Wqu?h??Z???OV??VO??>w????????????@,?m????>w???????r????q??m???????M?2????,Kroch?Q(1989)????,???????r????q??m?????m>P?h??????>W????>P?V???h,qD??>??m??>5????>W?????8???????k???h??@,?V????>????????????U>??t???r??,>??h?B?R>?????????q?q??m??,qD???S??????????,???m?S?r????>W??q??m?????k???h??@,??????????Kroch??>x>R?????????/??!(1989)@,>c???H>??????????)??@,>????l>o??,???8??>?>?>c??>w?????[>W??>?q?>??????[???T@,?v>?????Z?>c,?????4??>??m?S?r??????>W?h??????q??m?????[,Z??n??????????>????h,>????????h@,???k?h?????T??@,?v>?????Z?>c,?????4?????r?y??q??m?????[@,>?>???Z/?m???r?b??????>Wq??m,?]???????@>P?5?r?b??????>W@,?h?J,Z??n???????????????h,>?????>P?h@,???kq??y???T??@,???8,>??????8???T,Z??m???l>o????>?>w??>P?h?????[???M????:??>/?m>P?h??????>W>?>P?h??????????,??>/?m??>5????>W>????h??????????(Pintzuk2003:513)@,Bailey(1973)?(q??y???T??,?h????>R?0>5????>W?????8?????k>P?h??,Z??y??????1?S?R(Pintzuk2003:513):??1??1>W???5?????R????,???????R?????[q??m???????f???????[(????>c??),>r??????>???>r??>P?h??????(???k?????@???&????,?????:???r>r>5????,??>??h?J????)@,?hK?(?h?????T??,??>R??>5????>W?????8?????k???h??,Z????????y???????S?R(z35),??>W???5???????????L>Q?h??@,??2??2?????@????>??????????/??,?S?1??????!?k?:>o??>r??????>x?????MZ?????????@,?????H>??r??????>?????>????&,??Z;>f???????@??Z??????????:?R????@,??Z/,????????@,????Z??????[??q??m????(Z?q???????>c:?m??>5???v>W,????Z?>w>5?0>???>????(>W?????[?m??>5????>W??Z????y??,Z??)?????[????????>??f????;??>x,>???>???Z??????[??q??m????,??>P??Z??/??Z?>c?*????@,),?.?&???????v?????T,?m?U?:?:Z???????@,???J?H>??j??>????@>????????????????8???????c??@,Z??y,>P?h???:?R????@,?r??>o??????,?H>????@?????8???c??>??v?kS??????@,?j>??k?????6??,?h??>R>?q?>??)?????[?m?0>5????>W??q??m??Z???>?????,Kroch??Z?>?>?>5??????Z???:?f??Z???,????>R???kS???????????S@,>???Z????f???????Q?[??>c:(1)p=ek+st1+ek+st,p?k?????[??????,>?>?0??1>x??,s??k?k?d??,t>R????????@,?j?Q?[(1)??>?????Z??Q?[(2):lnp1-p=k+st,?Q?[????????>Rq??m???????f???????[(??logit)@,?Q?[(1)?kS??????,?h?Q?[(2)???????f???????[?l?k????,Z?>Ws?k??????????,k?k??????y?5??@,>o??>w>5Z??[?k???Q??,qD?Q?[(2)????????,????!?l?k?:?0>5????>W??s?k???Q??(Kroch1989:204)@,?m?????S>x>o,Kroch??>R,????Z??h???8?k??>R??>????k????>W??>????+???8???????B?R???[@,?????[?m?0>5????>Wq??m?????????,???e>?????????q?>o?????e,??>????e?k??????,????>?????>x?8@,???k?m?????????????/???????S>x>o,Kroch??Z?>???????>??y??@,??>o???S??,?m?????????8???c>W,??????>w???????/??Z?>???????Z????????(,>??h????>R>w?????????????r??,??>w???r???0>???>????(,??Kroch??>x>R??????>?!(1994)@,q???,?mEllegard(1953)?????S>x>o,Kroch????,??????do?m>W???????????T??>?????>W??>o?%?u??????>??????????/??,???m?????s????@(?s?????????Q>?>5>P?h??????>W,?S?r?????k???h??(?B???C?)??>x?&)@,?u????>??????)??,K(3)??????????q?Z?>???>c???????m>W??????>W,??Z????k?j>?>x?*????>W???????%(VI)>!?j#42#??>??8???6??2roch2Pintuk200:141sroch1987:21727:doto,doZ???>??&,??Z/??do??????>??mq??m@,???J,do??Z????l???e>????????%>&?s??>w????????????????????>?@,???m,??????doZ??????6?????]>R?v????????Z??2q?@,1.2??????>??y?????]?j??Z?>P????Kroch(1989)>???,CRE?m???????8?6??>W>P?????@????@,???l?[???S??????>??y?????m?????c??>o????>??]??@,q???,Kroch(1989)???6???B?R,?m>W?????????T,????>?q*??SVO????Z???,?/??Z???????>??(??@,Santorini(1989,1992,1993)???6???B?R,???Tq??v???m>??/?????&????(Ifinalstructure)?H?/????>W????(Imedialstructure)?????????c>W,??>w???????0>?????Z???????????>????(@,Pintzuk(1993,1996,1999)???6??>??B?R??????Z????h?J?????(@,Taylor(1990,1994)???6???B?R,???h?Y???m?L???????y?T>W?h?J???m?SOV??VO???T??????>???>?????Z?@,Frontana(1993)???6???B?R,???T????????>??/??????>?q*????q??C@,?hVance(1995)?Q???6??>??B?R,>W???????h>W???????????T????????>??J,>??/??Z?????>?q*??????Z???????>????((Pintzuk2003:5178)@,?V????????>??y??????>?>Pq????]?j,qD?hZ??????[????>??J,>??.???m???u>P??>x?0@,??Z/,??????Z???>?U????m???+?8?.??@,q???,?v?????????4?mZ?q?????>P?h????????????,???kq??mGB???T??????,q???>W???????*?R?L>?>W???????&!@(????>?q*?R?L>???????>?q*!?Q!2@,??>P>?>??k?)???k?s>&??q?????????,?????????k?????@?k?s>&P&P?)???????v????????????????@,Z??y,?V???v???????6???4>??[???@?????6?????.?????@?????????8??????????,qD???v>o?????r?????mP&P?)???D??Z????4???8???3??,>?????>B?v?????)??>?UO@,Z??4,?h???[?????????C?u??????????????>??J,q??m??????>??y?????6???4????>??4??????q??????????u?d>P>??2?Z,???v>o???k????Chomsky???0??Z?!??>5???P??????@,qD?T???????????????c????????????@(????,???v???????6???h?J?????T??????>??4,???r?????????????6????????@,???&,?V???v?????6????Z?????>???????????>W?=?)?d???????8????,qD???????8?????2??????,?v???????6???4???5?)??????>??y????>???>5?????????????2??>xZ???>?Z?????q*,>??h?e?]?6????????????????,?m??>?????>??????e?]>?>?>P???????)??>???@,>??fq?>o???c,>o????????>??y???????m???[?D????Z????????6??>W>??h?J???m@,?H>???>R,???k?h>?>5??????>P?h????,Z???>?>??T????>f???????k,?????????????C?????r??Z?U??@?&???????????8???)?????S(??>R?C?u?????4???6?????kZ???Z????)??????),?????r?m?????S>x>oZ???Z?>?>5?&?????????????8???R?.,>??h?e?]?)????????????????>x?????r?????@????,>???>????.qu>??T>o??????@,?r??>???,?H>??n???mP&P?)???D??Z?,??Z?>?>5?????????????????)???D??,>??T>????U??Z?>o???S?r????@,2.??>?P&P?)???????????????)???D???j???????????6???h??,Z??????k???????????j>??????????8?h???????????8????q?????@,??>/,?mP&P???)???D??Z?,???????????????????6???)??q???,???H???????@>?>cZ???:????Z?????????@(???????8??????@(???????8??>?????????>?(???????8>&??>??4??Z???)???????8???R?.?Q@,Z?>W,?????8???R?.??>R????,??>R???)>o??Z??????]>?>?>5>P???)??????q?@,>o???)???D???k?H>????????????8???)?????S@,2.1???????/?D??>W??????Z????mP&P?)?????*?T(??GB?.??),??>x>??????*???l???6??,??????????Z??6?????????j@,??>??.???????6??????????>?????>R?????????+?8,q????S?1????q*>f??????(thenullsubjectparameter)@(>W????????(headparameter)@(wh?????Q?Q?%?k????@,?H>?>?wh????(thewhparameter)>Rq???>????&,????>??m>c???????Q>w>5q??????B?R:(1)Whatdoyouthinkhewillsay?(2)Nirenweitahuishuoshenme?(q???>R>?qu??>?>/?!)??>o?S?R,??????????????????????????????????????,?h?Q??>W?????????????????0>?????????q*??>o>P??@,????????>o?????,?k?/??Z??????C??,??Z?????????>Rwh????@,?V?????.????????????>Q???r?????c????????,qDZ?q???????UO>???>??U??>??????????+????,>o??q??????k????@,???????+?8??qg???k,?H>???>??*??U??@?????&>??@????>?>?????>o?????,@,qDZ??R??>??k?B?h?1????,??>??????C>P?R>x?8,Z?>f???????m>?>P?s?K?????B?T?????>?C,??>P?h??????UO?????k?????U???B?T>??Tq??m?????#,>??h?m?3?v>o>&???l>&???????????v??????????@,????,???S?T?]????????>???????,?m??Z????????/?.??>x?&,Chomsky???T?]?????????k?x?????M>??C?????????2,????UO??Z???>???>x???T>????8@,?m???.??,????UO?Q>?????>W?????????[????,>6???.?S?B?T??q?(??>&>c??>W??>??4??q????????????:??Z?,???j?k?????6??>W????Z?????????????>f???)?j)@,?3???:Z????????/,???[?????)>R>w?C??,>????k?R????,??>????k?j????@,?R???????.quq??]#43#?????)??@(>????6?????????6??????????????>???????>??y????Z?q???,?h?j?????l>Pqu?e?]??>?????@,???????R?j>P?h?j?k?????8??q???@,?3??Chomsky(1995,2000,2001)????Z?????,???v??????>W???????r>r??,??C(?????:?R??)@(T(???()??D(?U????)(>?>???>R???m?S>c???????C,????>????k???P?+???????????k??,??>???>??????)>R?u???y>W????)@,?S?r???????????r???v??????>W????,qD??>??m????????>W?????????[?r???,(????>c??????Z?????)@,?H>?>c??>Bq??????]??@,?v>?>5q??U?k???T??>?????>W?S?1??VtoT????(?*?T?6??>W????>RVtoI????)@,?m???T??>?????>W,?????????????*,q?????????>????v>W,U?Thoumarvell%statmywords??Whoknowsnotthat????J?????U???????d??(Radford1997:253314)@,?m???.????????>W,????>W????T?4?L>??R?????[????[???(/>???]@,??>/,Z?>??d????????,marvell%st????>?V??q*?@T???M?????d??,>??h?e?]>??B?C??????@,?h?m??>?????>W,T>W???R????????>R?j????,?????@,>??j????>?V?@T??????@,??>/?????S?????????R?j?j???]>?>?>5????@,?h?J???),>o?????Q???????????????L>??k????>????[???????R?j@,Z?q??h??,????>W??????>W????C?4?L>?>5?R????[+Q],?S>????.?e?]what???B?C????@,?h?Q????????>W????C?4?L???l?k>?>5?j????[Q],>Pqu?e?]??Z?????@,??>/,????????[Q]???R?j?l???]>???>?>5????&@,???????/?.????????UO?k?????U???B?T>??Tq??m?????#,Z??v????>P?B?T>?????>WZ????????+??>???,???s?K?????B?T?????>?C,??>&???l>&?????????v??????Z?>???@,????q??m???[?D?????????6??,?C?u???6???4??????????>?U????m???+?8?.??,???&?B?????l>&?????????v????>P?s,?r??????>?????@,2.2?????????8???????S?1???????????8,?:?m????????>W???????T>????8@,?j>??v?????????6?????]???????k?m???P??>?Z????)??????,?????T?]?????????C???????????????8???????6??@,?V??Kroch??Pintzuk?Q???4>??????@?u???2?Z???8???????C,qD>?>????5>??3??>o???MZ?q???????@,???J???.qu???????8?6????>PZ????C,>??h????>??????6????????@,?h?S?1???????6??????,?j?k?:?????????8???6???????h???????8?8????(Elanguage),???????????8??????@,Z?>W???)????>???????,????>P?2?Z?8?????e????,?m???l>&???????)???D??Z?,??????q?>???>P?@???????8??????@,??>R?k>???????Z?????????????????>??&????>?????@,??>R????>????6???B?R,Z;???k???????R?h?f??????>??4@,?????rZ??)??qO??????,>?>?>P???????????,?B????????(Y)@,?T?]???????)?????:?k?6???????R????????,??Chomsky(1986)?????@????>??????6????????????Z????)???8@,?v>????)???8?j?k????Bloomfield????>f>Q?[>Q>o???????B??,>??h???d???[>Q>o??????!?A?4?M?U@,?????????B??>R?????4??q???>???????,?????r???????,,>????r?????Q??????Z?@,????>x,????>P>??k??>???,?h>6?k??????(Chomsky1986:1718)@,?v>????)???8?j?k>p?O?R?)Z??8???????8?8????,??>R?8?8??????>P???k>?>??M>R??>???,Z?Z?Z??????k?????R??????>???,???r?????)?6?????s????????Z??8???????6??(?h>o:1928)@,?v>r???)???8?j?k>p?O?R?)?d??????!(corelanguage)???8??!(periphery)@,>???>R,????>W??q??8????(??>P???l???(@(?]???Q)>P??>????l>&???????2??>xZ?,?h?kZ??8???]?)(?h>o:1479)@,>??T?]?????)?????:?????????c,>o???)???8???????C???????C????????@,qD??>o???S??,ZQ?3?????????????B??@(Z??8???????d??????,?H>??U?7??>???Z????????T???8??????@,??>/,???????8???.?k????>??T?????????B??@(?8?8???????8??@,Z???,>????H>??)??ZQ???H???C???2??,>o??????q??????2?h??,??>6?h???l>&???????)???D????Z???@,Z??z?k????????????Z????Cq??m??????????@,Z;??????>??T?????????B??,?m???J???B??>W,?j>??0??????????@(????????@(?0???Bqu???????????Q???e,Z;???????@???8???????=?)?P?+>6????>P??@,???????????.qu??>o????????????>??T????,>??h?r????????Z?>W???????????[>??T????,?????7?????????8(??>???q????8?l?k>c??????????Z???)@,?S>?,?j?????6?????????h??,?h??Z????T?????????????U?7?m?S??Z*!c@,2.3?????8>&??>??4Chomsky(1986:146)?m????Z;????q???????????,q??m>????0??Z?!??>5???P??????@,?V???????1??,?m?)??????>o>???>R???>,qD>?????>o?k????q?????>?????,?h??????????>?>????6???4??????????????,??>R?T???????????????c????????????@(????(Fodor2001:744)@,??>?????????????>??v???k?8?&?8??????>o????Z???????,>??h?????T??????>??4,>???>???>??????????????8?????#,>??h????????>??????6????????@,??????>?>/?J????>??4>&?????6???h?J???:??Z?@,?mP&P?)???D??Z?,?????????j??>??4?????]@,???!??>??4??q?Z???@(???/?@????????,?????T?]?????h???H?????k???C??????@,?H>???>????m??????>P?h?????!?????@??>x>R????>P?h????>??4@,???m???????k,?mq9?u????>??4??>W,?H>???????q??w????>?????>??4??????>??T??????>??4????j?????@?w?????:Z?????@,???)??????????>f??Z?????#44#??>??8???6??ang2000,???????P???r???+???????x!??>??4(Clark1994)@(???????!???x!??>??4(Lightfoot1997?Q)@(??????>????k!??>??4(Gibson&Wexler1994)@(???????k!??>??4(Clark&Roberts1993)??????????????>??4(StructuralTriggersLearner,STL)!?Q(Fodor2001:74450)@,??>?>????????v??????????>Q?C,?*??????>??4?????????(???m>?>c????:??>/????Z?q?????@(??>/>P???M@(??>/???/qD>PZ????8Z???qDq>?/,???????T??????>??4@,???????h??,???rSTL?*??>?U??@??Z????h?????/?@???M???????((Fodor2001:74450)(@,?????H>?>c??>W???@????>??4???kSTL@,?r>??????)??????>??4,>c???H>???????>?>??k??q???????????@,??>o???S??,????UO?Q?h>?????>W?????????[????(????????????),???????[???????.?4?L?m??>??+?????????[>x>W,???????[????>R?????????[)@,?T?]????????>??v??>R,??>5????UO???.>&??>5?????????!(cue)??????,??>/,??>??4????>???Z????????????[>W?????????!,>??h??????Z???????UO!9@,?m?u?d??Z?>c,?????8?8?????0>?>????????????(,??>??4????>??]???@???????!,>??h??????Z???????UO,???J>?>??j????>???Z??.???h?J??????@,qD??>o???S??,??>??4?????@???8?8?????u?d?=?)?P?+>6????>P??,>o????????>P???????#??????Z*,???j?[???S?&???4??????????>????.??>x???T???8,>??h?r?????????@?????????[,???h?????@??>??4???????!??????,>???>?????????????UO??????!,?????????8?l?j???h>??T@,2.4?????8???R?.?H>??m>o??>W?u?y???@??>??4?????????????T>????8,???????8????>??4????qu>??T>?>/?J???????>?>????????????c,?????????kZ????C??,??>RZ?quq??????????[>P???????y??@,??>/,????Ul??>??4qu????>?>/?J?????????????????S????3??????>??????6???]??,Z;???kq???????>??4,>?>??f?kUB?H>??r???????????????[,>?????????????@,???m???????k,?mP&P???)???D??Z?,q?>R?P?+???q?>R???????>o???S??,?m???????/?DZ?,?R???????.quq??]?B?C????,???j?[???SZ????.?r???????????[@,?????j????,Z?>???>?Z????)>R>w?[??,Z?>W>??[???hZ?q??????(?:???rZ?,????qu?j???????[?x>?Z?q???????Z???,>??j?k????>R?????????(?:??,??>o??>W???Q?????j????[Q]??????????Z?@,??>??[?????.>???>R???????[????,qD??>Pqu?rZ?q???????Z???,??????q???M????????U>W??[Q]??????????Z?(Roberts&Roussou2003:2930)@,???j?[???S,??>????[?????R?j>x?8,?????r?????????????[???]>???>?>5?????8??????@,??>?????,>???q??????????c,???????[?u??>w?????v?6??????>?????,??????(Move)???K??(Merge)@,>w?4????,?K?????????????>@,???m?)>o???S?rZ????u???2?Z,?H>??j??>????P?+????????>?Z?q???>Q@,??Z/,???P?+???????kZ??r>1???)?????R????,??>RZ??h???????@???????K??,?H>??mF*Move/Merge???R@,Z??y,?????P?+???k???r>1???)?????R????,Z?>P?????@?K??,?H>??mF*Move???R@,Z??4,>P?P?+???kZ??r???????????j????,Z????????@?K??,?H>??mF*Merge???R@,???&,??>P?P?+???????????????????[???j????,?H>??mF?????R(?*??>r>5???T???k?:?r???????????[)@,???J,?H>??j??>????@??>c?P?+?c???Q??+,q?>R????q?>R?P?+>???>??.:F*Move/Merge>F*Move>F*Merge>F(>???R??,,???P?+!)??>o???S??,Z;???kq???????>??4,>?>?UB?H>??r???????????????[,??>?????????????@,????,?m???????/???D??Z?,Longobardi?)?*?T??>??????l?????]????>c:?)????Z??????[?8!(2001:294)@,?j>????????????T>????8,>??hq??????????[?????y??,???j?[???S???????r???T?R???????!????>??4??????Z???????@,?3??>??????l,U%??>x?*?kF*Move/Merge????,??>??4????UlquUB?H>??r??F*Move,?j???l>??T???????8(???S?1???????)??,>c???????8?h?J????)@,q???,?(?6????>W??>??????[?j???????J?????8,Z????????8??>c:[AgrV+D[YP,>[AgrV[YP,(Roberts&Roussou2003:18792)@,?h?J???),????>x?*?kF*Move,??>/>????4?jqu?r??F*Merge@,q???,>o??>WVtoT?????????j??????????Z?@,????>x?*?kF*Merge,>????4?jqu?r??F@,q???,?h?Y??>Wtha????Z????8?j??>???????Z?(Roberts&Roussou2003:5871)@,?h??,?j>?>o???P?+?c???Q???k?????C??,????C@(T??D???k>??J,?????????????8?R?.?,?m>?????>W??????>?q?>?>5?Q??@,???8,>??)??>o??,?m>o???Q??>W>????m?S>??y??>?>5>?>o?Q?????????C,?h???l?[???S???????T>????????8,??????>???????Z?@,???8,>o???????8???k?S???C??,?????)?????8qu?m????Z?>??@???????P?+?C,q???>o??VtoT?????????j?h??q#???S??????doq??m??>o?%@,?????????????P?+?C?m?fq?>o???5???@????,????>??u???????y??????>??y??@,3??????>??y?????????]????>o???S??,?????????8???R?.?)??????Z?q?#45#?????)??@(>????6?????????6??????????????>???????>??y????Z?q???Jeanavuarie.,???]>???>?P&P?)?????????????????)???D??@,>c???H>??n???m???)???D??>c????????>??y????>??????]??,>??T??Z?>o????Z???????@,??Z/,???????????/?D??>W??????????,?H>??r??????????????>??y??>W????UO??Z???@,????>P>?>??k>&??q?????????,?h?k?????@?k?s>&P&P?????v??????>?????????@,???m???.??,????UO>P?k?????????C??????,?h?k????>W?????????[????,Z????.?S?B?T??q?,Z??v????>P?B?T>?????>WZ????????+??>???,???s?K?????B?T?????>?C@,?????@,??????>??k?:>w????????????UO>x??????>?@,Z?q?????,?j?k??>?????>W???????[???????R?j>x??????>??8,???????@??>??r????Z?????????>x??????>?@,q???,>o??>W?S?K???????T??>?????????>?????>WT???R?j,???j???]>?????????>??(??,>??h?/??>R>P?h??????>x??????>?@,Z??y,???????[?D?????????6???h?J??Z??????????T???8??????@,Kroch??Pintzuk?Q???4?V??>??????m??q?>o?2?Z???8???????C,qD>?>????5>??3??>o???MZ?q???????@,?S?1???3??,>??j?k>o??>WChomsky??>r???)???8??????????@,?j>?>&Z????6?????)?????:>P?h,?????6?????.???r>P?h??????@(?2????????@,???*?S??,?T?????????B??@(?8?8???????8?????]>?Z;??????>?????,???????8???.??>???@,?j?????6???h??,Z????j>???>??????????8,>??h?????????????????8?U?7?m?S??Z*@,qD??>?>5???????c,?????6??????????Z??????????&Chomsky>o????>r???)???8?k?K?)?????r?/??,??>??k?????6?????T?]?????SU?Z????y?z@,Z??4,??>o???S??,?v???????6???4?H??????????>??4?v?????6??,???v????>o????Z?!??????@,??????>??y?????*???T?]?????)???????C?y?z?m>?,?u?????????v>W?????C????,????>?>o??CRE,???m?????S>