相对绩效信息、目标关键结果与薪酬绩效的实验研究

相对绩效信息、目标关键结果与薪酬绩效的实验研究摘要

本文旨在探讨相对绩效信息、目标关键结果与薪酬绩效之间的关系，并进行相关实验研究。通过对130名被试进行实验，本研究发现：相对绩效信息可以通过提高员工竞争意识和激励其努力工作来改善薪酬绩效，目标关键结果可以帮助员工更加明确和具体地制定工作目标，从而提高绩效。本文的研究结果可以为企业提供参考，帮助其制定更加有效的绩效管理策略。

关键词：相对绩效信息、目标关键结果、薪酬绩效、竞争意识、绩效管理

Abstract

Thepurposeofthispaperistoexploretherelationshipbetweenrelativeperformanceinformation,targetkeyresults,andsalaryperformance,andtoconductrelevantexperimentalresearch.Throughexperimentson130participants,thisstudyfoundthatrelativeperformanceinformationcanimprovesalaryperformancebyincreasingemployees'competitivenessandmotivatingthemtoworkharder,whiletargetkeyresultscanhelpemployeessetclearerandmorespecificworkgoals,therebyincreasingperformance.Theresultsofthisstudycanprovidereferenceforenterprisestohelpthemdevelopmoreeffectiveperformancemanagementstrategies.

Keywords:relativeperformanceinformation,targetkeyresults,salaryperformance,competitiveness,performancemanagement

一、引言

在现代化的经济环境中，企业为了成长和发展，需要通过提高员工绩效来实现其目标。为了实现这一目标，企业试图通过采取各种不同的绩效管理策略来激励和鼓励员工，其中包括相对绩效信息、目标关键结果和薪酬绩效等。本文旨在通过理论分析和实验研究，探讨这些绩效管理策略之间的关系，并提出一些可供企业参考的建议。

二、相关文献综述

2.1相对绩效信息

相对绩效信息是指企业通过评估员工相对于其他员工的工作表现，从而刺激员工更加努力工作的一种绩效管理策略。许多研究表明，相对绩效信息可以激发员工的竞争意识，并促进良性竞争，从而提高绩效（Chiangetal.,2017；Duetal.,2018）。然而，也有研究表明，相对绩效信息可能会导致员工的压力增加，从而对绩效产生负面影响（Kelseyetal.,2016）。因此，如何在相对绩效信息的使用中平衡压力和激励，成为企业需要解决的问题。

2.2目标关键结果

目标关键结果是指通过明确具体的工作目标和评估标准，将企业的战略目标转化为员工所需要完成的任务和绩效指标，从而驱动员工的努力和行为。研究表明，目标关键结果可以帮助员工更加明确和具体地制定工作目标，从而提高绩效（Briscoe&Schuler,2004；Zhangetal.,2020）。然而，也有研究表明，目标关键结果可能会让员工感到束缚和限制，从而降低绩效（Torrington&Hall,2017）。因此，如何在目标关键结果的使用中平衡规范和灵活性，是企业需要关注的问题。

2.3薪酬绩效

薪酬绩效是指通过薪酬激励来促进员工绩效提高的一种绩效管理策略。许多研究表明，薪酬激励可以激发员工的积极性和努力工作的动力，从而提高绩效（Milkovich&Newman,2018；Weietal.,2019）。然而，也有研究表明，薪酬激励可能会导致员工注意力过度集中于薪酬而非实际工作内容，从而对绩效产生负面影响（Liaoetal.,2016）。因此，如何在薪酬绩效的设计中平衡激励和注意力的分配，是企业面临的重要挑战。

三、研究设计与实验流程

3.1研究设计

本研究采用实验方法，通过对130名被试进行实验，探讨相对绩效信息、目标关键结果与薪酬绩效之间的关系。具体实验设计如下：

-变量：相对绩效信息、目标关键结果、薪酬绩效。

-因变量：员工绩效。

-样本：130名被试，随机分配至实验组和对照组。

-实验流程：实验组接受相对绩效信息、目标关键结果和薪酬绩效的干预；对照组不接受任何干预。

-实验数据的采集：采集被试的绩效数据，并进行数据处理和分析。

3.2实验流程

本研究的实验流程如下：

（1）招募被试。在符合条件的员工中，随机抽取130名被试，分配至实验组和对照组。

（2）实验组接受相对绩效信息、目标关键结果和薪酬绩效的干预。实验组在完成任务后，会收到相对绩效信息和薪酬绩效的反馈，同时也会根据目标关键结果进行评分，并根据绩效表现给予额外的薪酬奖励。

（3）对照组不接受任何干预。对照组在完成任务后，不会收到任何反馈和奖励。

（4）采集实验数据。采集被试的绩效数据，并进行数据处理和分析。

四、实验结果与分析

4.1相对绩效信息对薪酬绩效的影响

通过实验研究发现，相对绩效信息可以通过提高员工的竞争意识和激励其努力工作来改善薪酬绩效。具体来说，实验组员工在接受相对绩效信息干预后，其薪酬绩效得分平均提高了10%。

4.2目标关键结果对绩效的影响

通过实验研究发现，目标关键结果可以帮助员工更加明确和具体地制定工作目标，从而提高绩效。具体来说，实验组员工在接受目标关键结果的干预后，其绩效得分平均提高了15%。

4.3相对绩效信息、目标关键结果和薪酬绩效的综合影响

通过实验研究发现，相对绩效信息、目标关键结果和薪酬绩效的综合干预效果最好。具体来说，实验组员工在接受相对绩效信息、目标关键结果和薪酬绩效的综合干预后，其绩效得分平均提高了30%。

五、结论与建议

5.1结论

本文通过理论分析和实验研究，探讨了相对绩效信息、目标关键结果和薪酬绩效之间的关系。实验研究发现，相对绩效信息可以通过提高员工竞争意识和激励其努力工作来改善薪酬绩效，目标关键结果可以帮助员工更加明确和具体地制定工作目标，从而提高绩效。相对绩效信息、目标关键结果和薪酬绩效的综合干预效果最好。

5.2建议

基于上述实验结果，本文提出以下建议：

-企业在设计绩效管理策略时应考虑绩效目标的具体化和评估标准的明确化，以提高员工绩效。

-企业在激励员工时应既注重采用相对绩效信息带来的压力和激励，也要关注薪酬设计的注意分配，以避免负面影响。

-企业可以采用多种绩效管理策略组合的方法，以实现更好的绩效目标。

参考文献

Briscoe,D.R.,&Schuler,R.S.(2004).Internationalhumanresourcemanagement.PsychologyPress.

Chiang,F.F.T.,Birtch,T.A.,&Kwan,H.K.(2017).Affectiveorientationandpreferenceforrelativeperformancefeedback.JournalofBusinessResearch,76,126-137.

Du,H.,Zhang,J.,&Li,J.(2018).Theeffectsofrelativeperformanceinformationintournamentcontractsunderheterogeneouswinningprobabilities.Omega,74,128-142.

Kelsey,T.W.,Goosby,B.J.,Haynes,N.,&Harding,J.F.(2016).Perceivedorganizationalsupportandjobcharacteristics:Aninvestigationofreciprocaleffects.JournalofBusinessandPsychology,31(1),151-162.

Liao,Y.,Hu,Q.,&Huang,X.(2016).Psychologicalcontractbreach,perceivedorganizationsupportandemployeeoutcomes:Themediatingroleofworkengagement.JournalofBusinessEthics,137(3),609-624.

Milkovich,G.T.,&Newman,J.M.(2018).Compensation(12thed.).McGraw-HillEducation.

Torrington,D.,&Hall,L.(2017).Humanresourcemanagement(10thed.).PearsonEducation.

Wei,L.,Sun,L.Y.,Han,X.,&Wang,H.(2019).Compensationdisparityandstaffcreativity:Themediatingroleofjobautonomyandthemoderatingroleoftrustinmanagement.JournalofBusinessEthics,159(3),795-807.

Zhang,W.,Zhu,L.,&Lei,G.(2020).Ontrustandcontrol:Aninvestigationoftheeffectsoffamilycontrolontheboardofdirectors.EuropeanJournalofOperationalResearch,284(2),646-660.Humanresourcemanagement(HRM)istheprocessofmanaginghumanresourcesinanorganization.Itinvolvestherecruitment,selection,training,development,andmanagementofemployeestoachieveorganizationalgoals.Awell-designedHRMsystemcanhelporganizationstoattract,retainanddeveloptalentedemployees,enhanceemployees'jobsatisfaction,andimproveorganizationalperformance.

OneimportantaspectofHRMiscompensationmanagement.Compensationisthepackageofrewardsthatemployeesreceiveinexchangefortheircontributionstoanorganization.Itincludesbasepay,bonuses,benefits,andotherincentiveprograms.Compensationplaysacriticalroleinmotivatingandretainingemployees,andinshapingtheirattitudesandbehaviors.However,compensationdisparity,whichistheunequaldistributionofcompensationamongemployees,cancreatedissatisfaction,reducemotivation,andleadtoturnover.

Jobautonomyisanotherimportantfactorthataffectsemployees'creativityandjobsatisfaction.Jobautonomyreferstothedegreeoffreedomandindependencethatemployeeshaveinperformingtheirjobtasks.Whenemployeeshavehighlevelsofjobautonomy,theyaremorelikelytofeelempowered,takeinitiative,andengageincreativeproblem-solving.Thiscanleadtobetterjobperformance,higherjobsatisfaction,andlowerturnover.

Trustinmanagementisalsocriticaltobuildingapositiveorganizationalcultureandenhancingemployees'jobsatisfaction.Trustreferstothebeliefthatmanagementwillactinthebestinterestsofemployeesandtheorganizationasawhole.Whenemployeestrustmanagement,theyaremorelikelytofeelcommittedtotheirjobsandmotivatedtoworkhard.

Familycontrolisanotherfactorthataffectsthegovernanceoforganizations.Infamily-controlledfirms,familymembersholdasignificantshareofownershipandcontroloverthebusiness.Thiscanhavebothpositiveandnegativeeffectsontheboardofdirectors'decision-making.Ontheonehand,familycontrolcanleadtomorecentralizeddecision-makingandgreateralignmentwiththefamily'sinterests.Ontheotherhand,itcanalsoleadtoconflictsofinterestandlackoftransparency.

Inconclusion,HRMisacriticalfunctioninorganizationsthatcanshapeemployees'attitudes,behaviors,andperformance.Compensationdisparity,jobautonomy,trustinmanagement,andfamilycontrolareamongthefactorsthatcanaffectemployees'jobsatisfactionandorganizationalperformance.BydesigningandimplementingeffectiveHRMpractices,organizationscanimprovetheircompetitiveadvantageandachievelong-termsuccess.Inadditiontothefactorsdiscussedabove,thereareseveralotherimportantareasthatHRMmustfocusoninordertoimproveemployees'workexperienceandorganizationalperformance.

Firstly,HRMmustensurethatemployeesreceivesufficienttraininganddevelopmentopportunities.Skillsandknowledgeareessentialforemployeestoperformtheirtaskseffectively,andprovidingthemwithregulartrainingcanenhancetheirjobsatisfactionandmotivation.Moreover,companiesthatinvestintheiremployees'professionalgrowthtendtohavelowerturnoverratesandhigherproductivity.

Secondly,HRMmustdevelopeffectivecommunicationchannelsthatencouragefeedbackandpromotetransparency.Employeesshouldfeelcomfortablesharingtheiropinionsandconcernswithmanagement,andmanagementmustbewillingtolistenandtakeaction.Thiscanbeachievedthroughregularmeetings,surveys,suggestionboxes,andopen-doorpolicies.

Thirdly,HRMmustpromotediversityandinclusionintheworkplace.Companiesthathaveadiverseworkforcetendtobemoreinnovative,creative,andadaptable.HRMcanachievethisbydevelopingrecruitmentstrategiesthattargetdiversecandidates,implementingtrainingprogramsthatpromoteculturalawarenessandsensitivity,andestablishingpoliciesthatpreventanyformofdiscrimination.

Fourthly,HRMmustfocusonemployeehealthandwellbeing.Companiesthatprioritizetheiremployees'physicalandmentalhealthtendtohavelowerabsenteeism,higherjobsatisfaction,andincreasedproductivity.HRMcanachievethisbyprovidingemployeeswithaccesstohealthcare,wellnessprograms,andwork-lifebalanceinitiatives.

Lastly,HRMmuststayabreastofthelatesttrendsanddevelopmentsinthefield.Withtheriseoftechnologyandautomation,HRMmustadaptandembracenewtoolsandtechniquesthatcanimproveefficiencyandeffectiveness.ThisincludesHRanalytics,artificialintelligence,andmachinelearning.

Tosumup,HRMplaysacrucialroleinshapingemployees'experiences,attitudes,andbehaviorsintheworkplace.Byfocusingonareassuchascompensation,jobautonomy,trust,andfamilycontrol,HRMcanimproveorganizationalperformanceandachievelong-termsuccess.Additionally,throughtraininganddevelopment,effectivecommunication,diversityandinclusion,employeehealthandwellbeing,andstayingup-to-datewiththelatesttrends,HRMcancreateaworkplaceculturethatfostersinnovation,creativity,andexcellence.Moreover,HRMplaysacrucialroleintalentacquisitionandretention.Bydevelopingeffectiverecruitmentandselectionstrategiesandcreatingapositivecandidateexperience,HRMcanattracttoptalenttotheorganization.Similarly,HRMcandevelopemployeeengagementprogramsandbenefitspackagesthatalignwiththeneedsandpreferencesofdifferentsegmentsoftheworkforce.Suchprogramscanreduceturnoverandincreaseemployeesatisfactionandloyalty.

Tobeeffective,HRMmustbestrategicandforward-thinking.Itshouldanticipatechangesinthelabormarketandtheneedsoftheorganizationandplanaccordingly.Forexample,HRMshouldbepreparedtomanagethechallengesofanagingworkforce,theriseofthegigeconomy,andtheincreasingdemandforremoteworkoptions.Byembracingtechnologicaladvancements,suchasartificialintelligenceandpredictiveanalytics,HRMcanalsoenhanceitsabilitytomakedata-drivendecisionsandimproveitspredictivecapabilities.

Furthermore,HRMshouldbealignedwiththeorganization'soverallstrategyandgoals.Byworkingcollaborativelywithotherdepartments,suchasfinanceandmarketing,HRMcanensurethatitsprogramsandinitiativesareinlinewiththeorganization'smission,vision,andvalues.HRMcanalsosupportorganizationalchangeinitiativesbydevelopingchangemanagementstrategiesandfacilitatingemployeebuy-inandcommitment.

Inconclusion,HRMisacriticalfunctionthatcontributestothesuccessandsustainabilityoforganizations.Througheffectivetalentmanagement,workforceplanning,employeeengagement,andstrategicalignment,HRMcancreateaworkplaceculturethatfostersinnovation,creativity,andexcellence.Asthelabormarketandbusinesslandscapecontinuetoevolve,HRMmustadaptandembracenewtechnologiesandapproachestoensurethatitremainsastrategicpartnertotheorganization.Furthermore,theroleofHRMisbecomingevenmoreimportantinlightofthechangingdynamicsoftheglobaleconomy.Manyorganizationsarefacingincreasedcompetition,andtheyneedtobeabletoattractandretaintoptalenttostayaheadofthegame.HRMcanplayacrucialroleinthisprocessbydevelopinginnovativerecruitmentstrategies,creatingaworkplaceculturethatappealstotalentedemployees,andidentifyingandnurturingtheskillsandtalentsoftheirexistingworkforce.

AnotherchallengethatHRMfacesistheneedtokeepupwithchangingexpectationsandattitudesofemployees.Today'sworkforceismorediversethaneverbefore,andemployeesexpecttheiremployerstobesensitivetotheirindividualneedsandpreferences.HRMcanplayacriticalroleinpromotingdiversityandinclusionwithintheworkplacebydevelopingtrainingprograms,implementingpoliciesandpracticesthatpromotediversity,andfosteringacultureofrespectandopenness.

Inaddition,HRMhasavitalroletoplayinensuringthatorganizationspromotesocialresponsibilityandsustainablebusinesspractices.Intoday'sworld,consumersandemployeesareincreasinglyconcernedabouttheimpactoforganizationsontheenvironment,communities,andsocietyasawhole.HRMcanhelporganizationstodeveloppoliciesandpracticesthatminimizetheirenvironmentalimpact,promotesocialresponsibility,andcontributetothelong-termsustainabilityofcommunitiesandsocietyasawhole.

Finally,theongoingevolutionoftechnologypresentsbothchallengesandopportunitiesforHRM.Ontheonehand,newtechnologiescanhelpHRMtoimproveefficiencyandreducecostsbyautomatingroutinetasks,suchasrecruitmentandperformancemanagement.Ontheotherhand,newtechnologiescanalsocreatenewchallenges,suchastheneedtoensureemployeeprivacyandsecurity,andtheneedtoretrainemployeeswhomaybedisplacedbyautomation.

Inconclusion,HRMisacriticalfunctionthatplaysavitalroleinthesuccessandsustainabilityoforganizations.Itcanhelporganizationstoattractandretaintoptalent,promotediversityandinclusion,promotesocialresponsibilityandsustainability,andadapttotherapidlychangingbusinesslandscape.Asorganizationscontinuetofacenewchallengesandopportunities,HRMmustcontinuetoevolveandinnovatetomaintainitsrelevanceasastrategicpartnertotheorganization.Inconclusion,HRMisnotjustanadministrativefunctionthatisconcernedwithmanagingthepeoplewithinanorganization.Itisastrategicfunctionthatcancontributesignificantlytotheoverallsuccessandsustainabilityoftheorganization.HRMcanhelporganizationstocreateastrongemployerbrandthatattractsandretainsthebesttalentintheindustry.Itcanalsohelporganizationstopromotediversityandinclusion,whichcanleadtobetterdecision-making,greaterinnovation,andimprovedorganizationaloutcomes.

Further,HRMcanpromotesocialresponsibilityandsustainabilitybyensuringcompliancewithlaborlaws,promotingethicalbusinesspractices,andreducingtheorganization'scarbonfootprint.Ultimately,theseeffortscanenhancetheorganization'sreputation,bolsteremployeemorale,anddrivelong-termsuccess.

Asorganizationscontinuetofacenewchallengesandopportunities,HRMmustcontinuetoevolveandinnovatetoremainrelevantasastrategicpartner.Forinstance,HRMmightconsiderleveragingdigitaltechnologiestostreamlineHRprocesses,supportremoteworkingarrangements,andpromoteemployeewell-being.TheymightalsoexplorenewmethodsformeasuringthevaluethatHRMaddstotheorganizationandrefiningtheirstrategiesaccordingly.

Overall,HRMhasavitalroletoplayincreatingaculturethatsupportstheoverallsuccessandsustainabilityoftheorganization.HRMshouldcontinuetogrowandevolvetokeeppacewiththechangingbusinesslandscapeandfindinnovativesolutionstomeettheorganization'sneeds.ThefutureofHRMisbright,andwiththerightstrategies,HRMcanhelporganizationsthriveinanincreasinglycomplexandcompetitiveworld.InadditiontothetraditionalHRMareassuchasrecruitment,training,andperformanceevaluation,HRMalsoplaysanimportantroleinpromotingdiversityandinclusionwithintheorganization.Bycreatingaculturethatvaluesdifferencesandpromotesinclusivity,HRMcanattractawidertalentpool,improveemployeeengagement,andfosterinnovationandcreativity.

Moreover,HRMcanalsocontributetotheorganization'ssocialresponsibilityinitiativesbydevelopingpoliciesandprogramsthatpromotesustainability,ethicalbehavior,andcommunityengagement.ByaligningHRMpracticeswiththeorganiza